Question 1
1 markA college has students in Year 12 and Year 13. Leo chooses a simple random sample of 50 students from a list of all the students. He then counts that 28 of them are in Year 12 and 22 are in Year 13.
Leo says, 'My sample is stratified by year group.'
Explain why Leo is wrong.
Model answer
Stratification happens before the sample is taken. Leo should first work out how many students to take from each year group, in proportion to the number of students in each year group in the college, and then choose that many at random from each year group. His numbers 28 and 22 are just what came out by chance, so they may not be in proportion.
Explanation
In a stratified sample the strata sizes are fixed in advance from the population, and then each stratum is sampled separately. Counting the groups after a simple random sample does not make it stratified. Stratified samples are proportional, not equal, so '25 from each year' is also wrong.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for explaining that stratification must be done before sampling: the number from each year group should be worked out first, in proportion to the numbers in each year group in the college, and then each year group sampled separately; Leo's 28 and 22 are just what happened by chance
oe. Accept 'he did not split the students into year groups before choosing them' or 'the numbers from each year group were not fixed in proportion to the college'. Do not accept 'his sample is random' or 'he should have chosen 25 from each year' (the numbers must be proportional, not equal).