Question 1
1 markHannah uses spreadsheet software to produce a bar chart of the number of people using a leisure centre on each day of one week.
The software offers a 3D effect, which shows each bar as a solid block seen from above and to one side.
Give one reason why Hannah should not use the 3D effect.
Model answer
With the 3D effect, the top of each block is drawn behind and above its front edge, so it is hard to see exactly where each bar meets the scale. The number of people on each day could not be read accurately, and the blocks may look bigger or smaller than they really are.
Explanation
A 3D effect is decoration: it adds no information and it distorts the picture, because the perspective changes how big each block looks and the tops of the blocks do not line up with the scale. Software makes effects like this easy to add, but a plain bar chart represents the data accurately.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for one correct reason, e.g.
- it is difficult to read the height of each bar against the scale (the top of each block is not level with the scale lines)
- the perspective can make some blocks look bigger or smaller than they are, so the comparison between days is distorted
- the 3D effect adds no information, it only makes the chart harder to read accuratelyoe. The reason must say how the 3D effect causes a problem. 'It is misleading', 'it is harder to read' or 'it is confusing' alone scores B0. Accept 'it is harder to read the values from the scale'.