Question 1
1 markA railway company wants to estimate the proportion of its passengers who have travelled without a valid ticket in the last month. It plans to ask a sample of passengers this question, using the random response technique.
'In the last month, have you travelled on our trains without a valid ticket?'
Give a reason why the random response technique is suitable for this question.
Model answer
Travelling without a valid ticket is against the rules, so it is a sensitive question. Many passengers would not admit it if asked directly. With the random response technique nobody can tell whether a passenger's Yes is true, so passengers are more likely to answer honestly.
Explanation
The technique is used when people may lie or refuse to answer because the question is sensitive or embarrassing. Some of the Yes answers are produced by chance, so an individual's answer cannot be used against them. A common error is to confuse it with random sampling: it does not give everyone an equal chance of being chosen.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a reason, e.g. travelling without a valid ticket is a sensitive question (it is against the rules / an offence), so passengers may not answer honestly if they are asked directly / this method keeps each passenger's answer confidential (anonymous), so they are more likely to tell the truth
oe. Accept 'it is a sensitive question', 'passengers may not answer it honestly otherwise', 'passengers may not want to answer it otherwise' or 'it makes the answers anonymous / confidential'. 'It is a personal question' on its own scores B0. B0 for answers about random sampling, e.g. 'every passenger has an equal chance of being chosen' or 'it removes sampling bias'. B0 for 'to get more accurate results' with no reason.