Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 1) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The statistical enquiry cycle
Statistical enquiry cycle stages 1 and 2; (a) Planning: 1a.01, 1a.02, 1a.03
Statistical enquiry cycle: planning and collecting
Statistical enquiry cycle stages 3, 4 and 5
Statistical enquiry cycle: interpreting and evaluating
Unit 2
The collection of data
(b) Types of data: 1b.01, 1b.02, 1b.03
Types of data and variables
(b) Types of data: 1b.04; (d) Collecting data: 1d.01, 1d.02
Primary and secondary data, reliability and validity
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.01, 1c.02, 1c.03
Populations, sampling frames and non-random sampling
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.04, 1c.05
Random and systematic sampling
(c) Population and sampling: 1c.06
Stratified sampling
(d) Collecting data: 1d.05, 1d.06
Problems with collected data and cleaning data
Unit 3
Processing, representing and analysing data
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01
Tabulation, tallies, pictograms and two-way tables
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01, 2a.02
Pie charts and comparative pie charts
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.01
Stem and leaf diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.02
Population pyramids, choropleth maps and 2D and 3D diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.04
Histograms and frequency density
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.05, 2a.06, 2a.07, 2a.08
Choosing representations and misleading diagrams
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.09, 2a.10
Skewness
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.01, 2b.02, 2b.03
Mode, median and mean
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.01
Weighted mean and geometric mean
(c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.01, 2c.06
Standard deviation and standardised scores
(a) Tabulation, diagrams and representation: 2a.03; (c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.02, 2c.03
Box plots and outliers
(b) Measures of central tendency: 2b.03; (c) Measures of dispersion: 2c.04, 2c.05
Comparing distributions
(d) Further summary statistics: 2d.01
Index numbers
(d) Further summary statistics: 2d.02
Rates of change
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.01, 2e.02, 2e.03
Scatter diagrams, correlation and causation
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.04
Lines of best fit and regression lines
(e) Scatter diagrams and correlation: 2e.05, 2e.06, 2e.07, 2e.08
Spearman's rank and product moment correlation coefficients
(f) Time series: 2f.01, 2f.02; (b) 2b.01 mean seasonal variation
Time series, moving averages and seasonal variation
(g) Quality assurance: 2g.01, 2g.02
Quality assurance and control charts
(h) Estimation: 2h.01, 2h.02, 2h.03
Estimation, sample size and capture-recapture
Unit 4
Probability
3. Probability: 3p.01, 3p.02, 3p.03, 3p.04
Probability, expected frequency and risk
3. Probability: 3p.05, 3p.06, 3p.10
Experimental and theoretical probability and bias
3. Probability: 3p.11
Binomial distribution
3. Probability: 3p.12, 3p.13
Normal distribution
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/40

Bias, sensitive questions and the random response technique

Practise 14 exam-style questions on Bias, sensitive questions and the random response technique for Edexcel GCSE Statistics (Higher Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 14 questions
  • 1–5 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
14 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

A railway company wants to estimate the proportion of its passengers who have travelled without a valid ticket in the last month. It plans to ask a sample of passengers this question, using the random response technique.

'In the last month, have you travelled on our trains without a valid ticket?'

Give a reason why the random response technique is suitable for this question.

Model answer

Travelling without a valid ticket is against the rules, so it is a sensitive question. Many passengers would not admit it if asked directly. With the random response technique nobody can tell whether a passenger's Yes is true, so passengers are more likely to answer honestly.

Explanation

The technique is used when people may lie or refuse to answer because the question is sensitive or embarrassing. Some of the Yes answers are produced by chance, so an individual's answer cannot be used against them. A common error is to confuse it with random sampling: it does not give everyone an equal chance of being chosen.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for a reason, e.g. travelling without a valid ticket is a sensitive question (it is against the rules / an offence), so passengers may not answer honestly if they are asked directly / this method keeps each passenger's answer confidential (anonymous), so they are more likely to tell the truth

    oe. Accept 'it is a sensitive question', 'passengers may not answer it honestly otherwise', 'passengers may not want to answer it otherwise' or 'it makes the answers anonymous / confidential'. 'It is a personal question' on its own scores B0. B0 for answers about random sampling, e.g. 'every passenger has an equal chance of being chosen' or 'it removes sampling bias'. B0 for 'to get more accurate results' with no reason.

Question 2

2 marks

Seren is investigating the heights of the students in Year 11 at her school. She asks each student to measure their own height at home and type it into an online form.

Explain how Seren's method could give inaccurate data.
Suggest how Seren could change her method to reduce this problem.

Model answer

Seren has no control over how the heights are measured. Some students may measure with their shoes on, some may use a different unit such as feet and inches, and some may just guess or round their height.

Improvement: Seren should measure every student herself, at school, using the same equipment, without shoes, and record each height to the nearest centimetre.

Explanation

When people collect their own data, the investigator loses control of how the measurements are made, and the data can be distorted. Measuring everyone in the same way, with the same equipment and the same unit and accuracy, reduces this. Asking for a bigger sample does not fix measurement problems.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for a reason, e.g. students may measure in different ways (with or without shoes, different equipment, different units) / students may round or guess their heights / students may exaggerate their height / students may make mistakes when typing their height

    oe. Seren has no control over how the measurements are made. B0 for 'students may lie' with no further detail. B0 for comments about the sample size.

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for an improvement, e.g. Seren (or one person) measures every student herself, at school, with the same equipment and in the same way (e.g. without shoes, to the nearest cm) / give clear instructions on how to measure, which unit to use and how accurately to record it

    oe. The improvement need not match the reason given. B0 for 'ask more students' or 'use a random sample' (these do not make the measurements more accurate). B0 for 'make sure students tell the truth' with no method.

Question 3

2 marks

A company asks all 500 of its employees to answer this question, in private.

Flip a fair coin.
If it lands on heads, tick Yes.
If it lands on tails, answer this question honestly.
In the last 6 months, have you taken office supplies home for your own use?
Yes   No

230 employees tick Yes.

Pat tries to use these results to estimate the proportion of employees who have taken office supplies home for their own use.

Explain why Pat cannot get a sensible estimate from these results, and give a possible reason for this.

Model answer

About \(0.5 \times 500 = 250\) employees should get heads and so tick Yes whatever the truth. But only 230 employees ticked Yes altogether, so the honest Yes answers would be \(230 - 250 = -20\), which is impossible. The estimate of the proportion would be negative.

A possible reason is that some employees who got heads ticked No instead of Yes, perhaps because they did not want to look guilty or did not understand the instructions.

Explanation

The random response estimate only works if people follow the instructions: the expected 250 forced Yes answers are taken away from the total number of Yes answers. When the total is below the expected forced number, the estimate is negative, so either people ignored the forced Yes or chance gave fewer heads than expected. This is a check worth making before using any random response result.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for about \(0.5 \times 500 = 250\) employees are expected to get heads and tick Yes, but only 230 ticked Yes, so the number of honest Yes answers works out as negative (\(230 - 250 = -20\)) / the estimate would be negative, which is impossible

    oe. Must show or state 250 (or 0.5) compared with 230. Accept 'there are fewer Yes answers than the coin alone should give'.

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for a possible reason, e.g. some employees who got heads did not tick Yes (they did not follow the instructions / did not want to appear guilty / did not understand) / by chance, fewer than half of the employees got heads

    oe. Accept 'the 250 is only an expected number; the actual number of heads varies'. B0 for 'nobody has taken office supplies home'. B0 for 'the sample is too small' (every employee was asked).

Question 4

4 marks

A supermarket wants to estimate the proportion of its customers who have, at a self-checkout, scanned an item as a cheaper item, for example by scanning expensive fruit as carrots.

Design a random response question that the supermarket could use in a survey of its customers.
Your answer should include the instructions that each customer must follow.

Model answer

Toss a fair coin where nobody else can see it.
If it lands on heads, tick Yes.
If it lands on tails, answer this question honestly.
In the last year, have you scanned an item at a self-checkout as a cheaper item?
Yes No

Explanation

A random response question needs a clear Yes or No question, a random device used in private, and instructions for every outcome. Some outcomes must force the answer Yes, so that a Yes cannot be traced to any one customer. A common error is to force the answer No for some outcomes, which leaves every Yes as a true admission; another is to forget one of the outcomes.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    B1 for a suitable question relevant to the information required, e.g. 'In the last year, have you scanned an item at a self-checkout as a cheaper item?'

    The question must have a Yes or No answer and be about scanning an item as a cheaper item (or paying less than the correct price at a self-checkout). Condone a missing time frame for this mark.

  2. 1 mark

    B1 for an instruction to generate a random outcome, e.g. toss a fair coin / roll a fair dice / spin a fair spinner / take a card at random

    Accept with or without 'in private'. B0 for 'think of a number' (not random).

  3. 2 marks

    B2 for a complete method to respond to the random response question: tick Yes for some outcomes and answer the question honestly for the other outcomes, with every outcome covered, e.g. 'If the coin lands on heads, tick Yes. If it lands on tails, answer the question.'
    (B1 for indicating to answer the question for some outcomes)

    For B2 the instructions must tell customers to tick Yes for some outcomes. A method that also has a forced No for some outcomes is fine (e.g. 1 or 2 tick Yes, 3 tick No, 4, 5 or 6 answer). A method with only a forced No, and no forced Yes, scores B1 at most. A method that leaves out an outcome (e.g. a dice with 1 to 5 assigned but not 6) scores B1 at most.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.