Question 1
1 markA company has made a new anti-fog coating for swimming goggles. It tests the coating on 40 pairs of goggles of the same type. 20 of the pairs, chosen at random, are given the coating. The other 20 pairs are not coated.
Swimmers wear the goggles, and the company records how long each pair takes to fog up.
Give a reason why the 20 pairs of goggles without the coating are needed in this experiment.
Model answer
The 20 uncoated pairs are a control group. Comparing the two groups shows how much longer the coated goggles stay clear because of the coating, rather than because of things that affect all the goggles, such as the water temperature or how long the swimmers swim.
Explanation
A control group is treated in the same way as the test group except for the one thing being tested. Without it, the company could not tell whether the goggles would have stayed clear just as long anyway. Vague answers such as 'to see if it works' miss the key idea of comparison.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for they are a control group: they give something to compare with, so that any difference in the time before the goggles fog up can be put down to the coating (rather than to other factors such as the water temperature or the swimmers)
oe. Accept 'to compare coated goggles with uncoated goggles' or 'it controls for extraneous variables'. B0 for 'to see if the coating works' with no idea of comparison. B0 for 'to make it a fair test' with no reason.