Question 1
1 markA bakery makes loaves of bread with a target mass of 800 g. Every hour, a sample of 6 loaves is weighed and the mean mass of the sample is recorded on a control chart.
The manager decides to use a second control chart, for the range of the masses of the loaves in each sample.
Explain why a control chart for the sample ranges is useful as well as the control chart for the sample means.
Model answer
The chart for the means only checks the average mass of the loaves in each sample. A sample could have a mean close to 800 g even though some of its loaves are much too heavy and others much too light. The chart for the ranges checks that the masses of the loaves are consistent, so it would show this problem.
Explanation
A control chart for sample means checks the location of the process (is it on target?), while a chart for sample ranges checks its spread (is it consistent?). A process can go wrong in either way, which is why the two charts are often used together. Answers that say only that the range is 'more accurate' do not explain what the range measures.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for explaining that the range checks how consistent (spread out) the masses in a sample are, e.g. a sample mean can be close to 800 g even when some loaves are much too heavy and others much too light
oe. Accept e.g. 'the mean only checks the average mass, the range checks the variation in the masses' or 'the range shows whether the loaves are all about the same mass'. B0 for 'to check the loaves are the right mass' (that is what the chart for the means does), 'the range is more accurate' or 'the range is more reliable' with no reference to spread, variation or consistency.