Question 1
1 markTwo bookshops, Bookshop A and Bookshop B, recorded the type of each book they sold last week. The pie charts show the results.
Theo says, "The two bookshops sold the same number of crime books last week, because the crime sectors have the same angle."
Explain why Theo might be wrong.
Model answer
Each crime sector is 90°, so crime books were \(\dfrac{90}{360} = \dfrac{1}{4}\) of each bookshop's sales. But the pie charts do not show how many books each shop sold altogether. If Bookshop B sold more books than Bookshop A, a quarter of its sales is more books, so the numbers of crime books would not be the same.
Explanation
Equal angles in two ordinary pie charts mean equal proportions, not equal frequencies. To compare numbers you also need each chart's total; comparative pie charts, whose areas show the totals, would make this possible. Saying only that the pie charts look different does not answer the question.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for an explanation that the pie charts show the proportion of each shop's books, not the number, and the two shops may have sold different numbers of books altogether
oe, eg 'the same angle only means the same fraction (a quarter) of each shop's sales', 'we do not know how many books each shop sold', 'if Bookshop B sold more books in total, it sold more crime books'. Allow an implication that the totals may be different, eg 'we do not know the totals'. B0 for 'the pie charts may not be accurate', 'there is no key', or 'Theo is right because the angles are equal'. Ignore extraneous non-contradictory comments.