Question 1
1 markIn a science lesson, Lily timed how long, in seconds, a toy car took to roll down a ramp. She did this 11 times.
2.4 2.5 2.5 2.6 2.6 2.7 2.7 2.8 2.8 2.9 6.3
Lily wants to use an average to describe the typical time.
Give a reason why the median is more appropriate than the mean for these data.
Model answer
One time, 6.3 seconds, is an extreme value: it is much longer than all the others, perhaps because the car hit the side of the ramp. It makes the mean (2.98 seconds) greater than 10 of the 11 times, but it does not affect the median (2.7 seconds).
Explanation
The mean uses every value, so a single extreme value pulls it towards itself; the median depends only on the middle of the ordered data. Use the median when there are outliers or the data are skewed. Saying the data are 'spread out' does not explain the choice: data can be widely spread with no extreme values.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for a reason that refers to the extreme value, eg the median is not affected by the extreme value / outlier of 6.3 / the mean is increased by the one much longer time of 6.3 seconds / the data are (positively) skewed
Accept anomaly or outlier for extreme value. Accept 'the mean (2.98 seconds) is greater than 10 of the 11 times, so it is not typical' or 'the 6.3 is probably a mistake, and it would change the mean but not the median'. B0 for 'the data are spread out' (a common incorrect response), 'the median is the middle value' on its own, 'the median is more accurate / more reliable' with no reason, or 'the mean is not a whole number'. Ignore extraneous non-contradictory comments.