Question 1
1 markIn 2024, a city with a large university had a crude birth rate of 9.0 and a crude death rate of 9.8
The population of the city still went up during 2024.
Explain how the population of the city could go up when its crude death rate was higher than its crude birth rate.
Model answer
The rates show a natural decrease: there were 0.8 more deaths than births for every 1000 people. But a population also changes through migration. If more people moved into the city (for example new students starting at the university) than moved out, and this net gain was greater than the natural decrease, the population would still go up.
Explanation
Births and deaths give the natural change in a population; migration into and out of the area also changes it. Here the natural change is a decrease of 0.8 per 1000, so the population can only rise if net migration into the city is bigger than that. The word 'crude' means the rate is for the whole population, not that it is inaccurate.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for more people moved into the city than moved out, and this net gain was greater than the number by which deaths were more than births oe
There must be a comparison: the net number moving into the city (eg new students) is greater than the natural decrease. Accept 'more people moved into the city than left it and died' or 'immigration (eg students arriving) was more than the 0.8 per 1000 by which the death rate is above the birth rate'. Do not accept 'people moved into the city' or 'students arrived' with no comparison. B0 for: 'more people were born than died', the data may be inaccurate, or 'crude means the rates are not accurate'.