Question 1
1 markA study of people with hay fever found that the relative risk of a hay fever attack on a high-pollen day, compared with a low-pollen day, is 1.6
Here are four statements.
A On a high-pollen day, 60% of people with hay fever have an attack.
B On a high-pollen day, an attack is 1.6% more likely than on a low-pollen day.
C On a high-pollen day, an attack is 60% more likely than on a low-pollen day.
D On a high-pollen day, an attack is 160% more likely than on a low-pollen day.
Which statement is a correct interpretation of the relative risk?
Choose your answer.
- A
- B
- C
- D
Model answer
Relative risk 1.6 means the risk on a high-pollen day is 1.6 times the risk on a low-pollen day.
1.6 times as likely = 60% more likely.
Answer: C
Explanation
Relative risk compares two absolute risks by division, so 1.6 means 'one and six tenths times as likely', which is an increase of 60%. It says nothing about what proportion of people have an attack (statement A). '160% of the risk' is correct, but '160% more likely' is not - a common mistake, because 160% more would mean 2.6 times as likely.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for C
cao. A relative risk of 1.6 means 1.6 times as likely, which is 60% more likely. A treats the relative risk as an absolute risk; B and D misread 1.6 as a percentage increase (D is the common error of saying '160% more likely' for '160% of'). More than one letter chosen: B0.