Question 1
1 markA music school wants to find out how well its students can play the piano. It gives every student a written test about reading music and music theory.
Explain why this test may not be a valid way of measuring how well the students can play the piano.
Model answer
A written test measures what students know about reading music and music theory. It does not measure how well they actually play the piano, because nobody plays in the test, so it does not measure what the school intended to measure.
Explanation
Validity is the extent to which a test measures what it was intended to measure. Knowing music theory is linked to playing well, but it is not the same skill, so a written test is not a valid measure of playing; listening to each student play the same pieces would be more valid. Comments about cheating or guessing are about honesty or reliability, not validity.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for explaining that a written test measures knowledge of reading music and music theory, not the ability to play the piano, so it does not measure what the school intends to measure
oe. Accept 'a student could know the theory well but play badly (or play well but do badly in a written test)' or 'nobody plays the piano in the test'. Do not accept answers about reliability or fairness alone, e.g. 'students may cheat', 'students may guess', 'the test may be too easy' or 'the test is too short', with no reference to what is being measured.