Question 1
1 markMr Evans recorded the times, in seconds, that 10 students in his Year 10 PE class took to run 100 metres.
15.3 14.8 16.2 1.42 13.9 17.1 15.8 14.4 16.7 15.1
By inspection, write down the time that is likely to be an error. Give a reason for your answer.
Model answer
1.42 seconds. Nobody can run 100 metres in 1.42 seconds, so this time cannot be genuine. It is probably 14.2 seconds with the decimal point in the wrong place.
Explanation
An outlier can often be spotted by inspection: 1.42 is far below every other time. Being an outlier does not by itself make a value an error, but here the context shows it must be one, because 100 m in 1.42 seconds is far faster than any human can run. Saying only that it is an outlier or much smaller than the rest does not explain why it is an error.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 for 1.42 (seconds) with a reason in context, e.g. it is impossible for anyone to run 100 m in 1.42 seconds / it is far too fast to be a real time (so the decimal point is probably in the wrong place and the time should be 14.2 seconds)
Both the value and a reason are needed. The reason must refer to the time being impossible or unrealistic for running 100 m; accept 'even the world record is over 9 seconds' oe. B0 for 'it is an outlier' or 'it is much smaller than the other times' alone (this only restates the data). Ignore a suggested correct value.