Question 1
1 markScientists think that much of the carbon dioxide in the Earth's early atmosphere was removed by processes that formed rocks.
Which observation is evidence for this idea?
Choose your answer.
- A Chalk and limestone contain calcium carbonate from the shells of sea creatures.
- B Ice cores contain bubbles of air that are thousands of years old.
- C The atmosphere of Venus today is mostly carbon dioxide.
- D Volcanoes today release carbon dioxide and water vapour.
Model answer
A
Explanation
Chalk and limestone are carbonate rocks. The carbonate in them came from carbon dioxide that dissolved in the oceans and was used by sea creatures to build calcium carbonate shells, so these rocks show that carbon dioxide was removed from the atmosphere and locked up in rock. The other options are true statements, but they are evidence about other things: what the early atmosphere contained, where its gases came from, or the air in the recent past.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / Chalk and limestone contain calcium carbonate from the shells of sea creatures
The only correct answer is A: the carbonate in these rocks came from carbon dioxide that dissolved in the oceans and was locked up in shells, so the rocks show that carbon dioxide was removed from the atmosphere and stored in rock. B is not correct because ice cores give evidence about the air in the last few hundred thousand years, not about how carbon dioxide was removed billions of years ago; C is not correct because the atmosphere of Venus is evidence for what the early atmosphere may have contained, not for how carbon dioxide was removed; D is not correct because it is evidence for where the carbon dioxide came from, not for how it was removed. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.