Item C
Paper Lantern Cards
Gethin owns Paper Lantern Cards, an independent card and gift shop on a busy shopping street in Swansea. Most of the shop's sales revenue comes from greeting cards, which it buys from suppliers and sells at an average price of £3.50 each.
The business environment around the shop has changed quickly. More people now send birthday messages by phone or on social media, and large online companies let customers design a personalised card, which they print and post for them. Higher prices for food and energy also mean that many of Gethin's customers have less money to spend on gifts.
Customers' environmental expectations are changing too. Several regular customers have complained that most of the shop's cards are wrapped in plastic film and decorated with plastic glitter. Gethin has found a supplier of plastic-free cards made from recycled card, but they cost the shop 9p more per card than his current range. A rival shop nearby now promotes itself as 'plastic-free', and the local newspaper wrote an article about it last month.
Gethin is considering spending £6 500 on a website on which customers could design their own personalised cards. The shop would print the cards on a new printer and post them, charging £4.25 a card plus postage. A web designer has warned Gethin that online sales take time to build, and that he would need to pay for online advertising to compete with the large online card companies. Gethin already works six days a week in the shop.
Table 1 shows the shop's sales revenue for the last three years.
Recommend whether Gethin should spend £6 500 on a website to sell personalised cards online.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Gethin should spend the £6 500 on the website, as long as he also plans for the advertising and the time it will need.
The main reason is that technology has changed how people buy cards. Table 1 shows that card revenue has fallen every year, from £96 000 in 2023 to £81 600 in 2025, a fall of 15%, while gifts and wrapping have stayed at about £54 000. More people send messages by phone, and large online companies let customers design a personalised card that is posted for them. If Gethin only sells through the shop, his card sales are likely to keep falling, and total revenue has already dropped from £150 000 to £135 500. A website would let him reach customers outside Swansea and sell a personalised product at £4.25, more than his average shop price of £3.50, so each online sale brings in more revenue.
However, there are strong reasons against. The large online card companies are well known and spend heavily on advertising, and the web designer has warned that online sales take time to build. Gethin would need to sell about 1 500 cards just to bring in £6 500 of revenue, before paying for printing, postage and advertising. Customers also have less money to spend. Gethin already works six days a week, so designing, printing and posting orders could leave him no time to run the shop well unless he pays for extra staff, which would add to his costs.
On balance, I still recommend the website, because doing nothing means accepting a steady fall in his biggest source of revenue. Its success depends on whether he can make his cards different from the large companies, for example by offering plastic-free cards, which would also meet changing environmental expectations. If he cannot afford enough advertising, he should start with a simpler website and build it up as sales grow.