Item A
Wyncote Street Coffee
Wyncote Street Coffee is a sole trader business owned by Priya, who opened her coffee shop on a busy street near the university in Nottingham three years ago. She roasts her own beans in the shop, and Wyncote Street Coffee is known for its comfortable seating, friendly staff and fast wi-fi. About 60% of her customers are students.
In September a national coffee chain opened a branch two doors away. Its drinks cost an average of £2.95, while Priya's drinks cost an average of £3.60. Since the chain opened, Wyncote Street Coffee's sales have fallen from about 2 100 drinks a week to 1 750.
Priya is considering competitive pricing: cutting her prices to match the chain's. On average, each drink costs her £1.45 in ingredients and cups. Her fixed costs, including rent, are £2 400 a week, and her landlord has just increased her rent by 10%.
In a survey of 200 customers, 115 said they would keep visiting Wyncote Street Coffee even if its prices stayed higher than the chain's, because of the quality of the coffee and the atmosphere. However, many students said that price was the main reason they had tried the new chain. The chain also offers a loyalty app that gives customers every tenth drink free.
Recommend whether Priya should cut her prices to match the prices charged by the coffee chain.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Priya should not cut her prices to match the coffee chain.
At the moment Priya earns £2.15 on each drink (£3.60 - £1.45). At 1 750 drinks a week this gives £3 762.50, which covers her fixed costs of £2 400 and leaves a profit of £1 362.50 a week. If she cut her average price to £2.95, she would earn only £1.50 a drink. Even if sales returned to 2 100 drinks a week, her profit would fall to £750 (2 100 × £1.50 = £3 150, minus £2 400). To keep her current profit she would need to sell about 2 509 drinks a week, which is more than she sold before the chain opened. With her rent having just risen by 10%, she cannot afford such a big cut in her margin.
Matching prices could win back some price-sensitive students, who make up about 60% of her customers and who said that price was the main reason they tried the chain. However, the chain also offers a loyalty app that gives every tenth drink free, so even at the same price some students may still prefer it. A national chain can also afford to cut its prices further if Priya matches them, starting a price war that a sole trader is likely to lose.
Wyncote Street Coffee has things the chain does not: beans roasted in the shop, comfortable seating, friendly staff and fast wi-fi. In her survey, 115 of 200 customers (57.5%) said they would keep visiting even if her prices stayed higher. This suggests she should compete on quality rather than price, for example by starting her own loyalty card or a student offer at quieter times.
Overall, cutting prices to £2.95 would greatly reduce her profit unless sales rose well above their previous level, which is unlikely. The decision depends on how many students she has lost for good, but she should keep her prices and promote what makes Wyncote Street Coffee different.
Explanation
The strongest answers use the figures in Item A to show what a price cut does to profit: the margin falls from £2.15 to £1.50 a drink, so Priya would need far more customers just to stand still. They balance this against the case for cutting, such as the students' sensitivity to price, and reach a decision that weighs up what it depends on. Answers that simply say 'lower prices mean more customers' without considering costs, the survey or the chain's response stay in the lower levels.