Item A
Spokeworks
Tomasz is a qualified bike mechanic who plans to start Spokeworks, a mobile bike repair service in York, as a sole trader. He would drive a fully equipped van to customers' homes and workplaces and repair bikes on the spot, so customers would not need to take their bikes to a shop. He has £9 000 of savings and would need a bank loan of £14 000 to buy and fit out the van.
To find out whether there is enough demand, Tomasz carried out a questionnaire with 400 cyclists. He stopped people on cycle paths around the city and also asked members of his own cycling club. Figure 1 shows the answers to one question: 'Would you use a mobile bike repair service?'
Tomasz also carried out internet research. A report by a local cycling charity says that about 12 000 adults in the area ride a bike at least once a week. Tomasz expects each customer to spend an average of £45 a year with Spokeworks.
Many people who answered 'Probably not' or 'Definitely not' wrote that they already use one of the four bike shops in York, which all offer repairs, or that they repair their own bikes. Several people who answered 'Definitely yes' wrote that they would pay extra for a repair at their workplace, so that they would not have to take time off work. Tomasz estimates that his running costs in the first year, including fuel, parts, insurance and loan repayments, will be about £52 000.
Recommend whether Tomasz should start Spokeworks.
Give reasons for your recommendation. Use the market research findings in Item A to support your answer.
Model answer
I recommend that Tomasz should start Spokeworks, but with care.
The market research suggests there is enough demand. Figure 1 shows that 15% of the 400 cyclists answered 'Definitely yes'. Applying this to the 12 000 adults who cycle every week in the area gives 1 800 customers, and at £45 each that is forecast revenue of £81 000 a year. This is well above the expected running costs of £52 000, which already include loan repayments, so Tomasz could make about £29 000 in the first year. The forecast is also cautious, because it ignores the further 25% who answered 'Probably yes'. The qualitative comments are useful too: several 'Definitely yes' customers would pay extra for repairs at their workplace, so Tomasz has found a clear target market of commuters and a unique selling point that the four bike shops in York cannot offer, because customers do not have to take time off work.
However, the findings may not be reliable. Part of the sample came from Tomasz's own cycling club, and these people may be keener cyclists than average or may want to support him, so the 15% could overstate demand. Saying 'Definitely yes' in a questionnaire is also not the same as paying for a repair. Most people surveyed (60%) said 'Probably not' or 'Definitely not', many because they already use a bike shop or repair their own bikes, so competition is strong. If revenue were a third lower than forecast, at about £54 000, Tomasz would only just cover his costs, and as a sole trader he would still have to repay the £14 000 loan.
On balance, the research is positive enough for Tomasz to go ahead, because even a cautious forecast covers his costs, and the workplace service gives him a clear advantage over the bike shops. The decision depends on how representative his sample was, so before buying the van he could check demand by contacting large employers in York to see whether they would book regular workplace repair days.
Explanation
Top-level answers use the research findings rather than just describing them: for example, calculating forecast revenue of £81 000 from Figure 1, comparing it with £52 000 of costs, and then questioning whether a sample that includes Tomasz's own cycling club is reliable. Any recommendation can reach Level 3 if it is justified and the conclusion says what it depends on. Answers that only say 'he should do more research' without weighing the evidence, or that ignore the case, cannot go above Level 2.