Item A
Warmwise Insulation Ltd
Warmwise Insulation Ltd installs loft and wall insulation in homes across Yorkshire. Insulation reduces heating bills, but every home is different, so customers usually have questions about the cost, the mess and how long the work will take. Most of Warmwise's customers are homeowners aged over 55.
Warmwise sells through a telesales team of eight staff in its Wakefield office. They phone people who have asked for information through the company's website or at home improvement shows, and past customers who might want more work done. Each member of the team makes 50 calls a day, five days a week, and 2% of calls lead to a sale. The average sale is worth £1 500. The telesales team costs £210 000 a year in wages and phone costs.
Some people have complained that the team calls too often, and several online reviews mention 'pushy' phone calls. Two competitors now let customers enter details of their home on a website, receive a price straight away and book an installation online.
The sales director wants to replace the telesales team with a new e-commerce website. It would cost £60 000 to build, plus £45 000 a year in online advertising. Customers could get a price, book an installation and pay a deposit online at any time of day. The finance director is worried that many older customers prefer to speak to a person before spending £1 500, and that some people who are not called may never get round to buying.
Recommend whether Warmwise Insulation Ltd should replace its telesales team with an e-commerce website.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Warmwise should not replace its telesales team completely, but should add an e-commerce website alongside a smaller team.
The website has advantages. The telesales team costs £210 000 a year, while the website would cost £60 000 to build and £45 000 a year in advertising, so after the first year Warmwise would save £165 000 a year. Customers could get a price and book at any time of day, which matters because two competitors already offer instant online prices, and customers comparing firms may choose them if Warmwise cannot give a quick price. Ending telesales would also stop the complaints and reviews about 'pushy' calls, which are damaging Warmwise's reputation.
However, the telesales team is very effective. Eight staff making 50 calls a day, five days a week, make 2 000 calls, and 2% lead to sales, so the team brings in 40 sales worth £60 000 every week, over £3 million a year. Its cost is only about 7% of the revenue it generates. Most customers are over 55, and because every home is different they usually have questions about cost, mess and timing, so many may not trust a website price for a £1 500 job and would rather speak to a person. The team also contacts people who have asked for information and past customers, creating sales that might never happen otherwise. The saving of £165 000 a year is only about 5% of the £3 million of sales the team brings in each year, so if the website led to even a modest fall in sales, the profit lost on those jobs could cancel out the saving.
Overall, removing telesales is too risky because it would put a proven £60 000 a week of sales at risk to save a relatively small cost. Warmwise should build the website so customers who prefer it can get instant prices, while keeping a smaller team that only calls people who have asked for information, and calls them less often to stop the complaints. This depends on how many customers book online; if online bookings grow strongly, the team could be reduced further later.