Item A
Tonnau Surf School
Rhian Morgan set up Tonnau Surf School as a sole trader four years ago. She teaches surfing on a beach near St Davids in Pembrokeshire from April to October. Most of her customers are families on holiday and groups of friends aged 18 to 30. A two-hour group lesson costs £40 per person. Lessons are usually fully booked in July and August, but there are many empty places in April, May, September and October.
Rhian promotes the business mainly through social media. She posts short videos of lessons, shares customer reviews and runs a monthly competition in which people who share her posts can win a free lesson. This takes her about eight hours a week, usually in the evenings after teaching.
Last season Tonnau had 1 250 customers. Rhian asked every customer how they had first heard about the business. The results are shown in Table 1.
A regional tourist magazine, given free to visitors at campsites, hotels and holiday cottages across Pembrokeshire, has offered Rhian a full-page advert in every issue from April to October for £2 400. The magazine says it is read by 60 000 visitors each season. Rhian estimates that 0.25% of the magazine's readers would become customers.
Rhian made a profit of £21 000 last season and has £3 000 in the business bank account. Two other surf schools have opened on nearby beaches in the last two years, and one of them already advertises in the magazine.
Recommend whether Rhian should pay £2 400 to advertise in the regional tourist magazine.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Rhian should pay for the advert, but she should use it to fill places in the quieter months.
The magazine reaches exactly the right people. It is given free at campsites, hotels and holiday cottages, so its 60 000 readers are visitors to Pembrokeshire, and families on holiday are Rhian's main target market. Leaflets at campsites already brought in 12% of last season's 1 250 customers, which is 150 customers, so there is evidence that holidaymakers respond to printed promotion where they stay.
The advert also looks good value. If 0.25% of readers become customers, that is 150 new customers paying £40, which is £6 000 of extra revenue from an advert costing £2 400, or £16 per new customer. As Rhian teaches the lessons herself, most of this revenue would add to her profit. In addition, one of the new rival surf schools already advertises in the magazine. If Rhian does not, readers will only see her competitor and may book with them instead.
However, there are risks. The advert would use £2 400 of the £3 000 in her bank account, leaving only £600 if equipment needs replacing early in the season before much revenue comes in. Also, lessons are already fully booked in July and August, so new customers wanting lessons in the summer holidays cannot be served; the extra revenue only comes if they book in April, May, September or October. Social media and recommendations already bring in 78% of her customers at very little cost, so she does not depend on the magazine.
Overall, the advert is worth paying for, because £6 000 of potential revenue is much greater than the £2 400 cost, and it stops the rival having the magazine's readers to itself. The decision depends on whether the 0.25% estimate is realistic, so Rhian should include a discount code for spring and autumn lessons in the advert. This would fill her empty places, and the code would show her whether the advert has worked before she pays for it again next year.