Item A
Tregarrow Farm
Tregarrow Farm is a 140-hectare farm near Bodmin in Cornwall. It is run as a partnership by Morwenna and her brother Jory, who took it over from their parents eight years ago. The farm grows potatoes, wheat and barley. It sells most of its potatoes to a food processor under a contract that has three years left to run.
The farm's main tractor is 17 years old. Last year it broke down four times during the harvest, and on one occasion the farm missed a delivery and had to pay the food processor a £2 400 penalty. The partners have decided to replace it.
A new tractor has a cash price of £68 000. The farm made a net profit of £41 000 last year, but the partners took most of this out of the business for themselves, and the farm's bank balance is now only £9 500. Farm income is seasonal: most cash comes in between August and November, when the crops are sold.
The tractor dealer has offered a hire purchase agreement: a deposit of £8 000, followed by 48 monthly payments of £1 450. The farm would own the tractor only after the final payment, and if it missed payments the dealer could take the tractor back.
Alternatively, the partners could sell 12 hectares of land that the farm does not currently use. A neighbouring farmer has offered £70 000 for it. Jory thinks the land might be needed if the farm grows in future. Morwenna points out that it earns the farm nothing at the moment.
Recommend whether Tregarrow Farm should use hire purchase to buy the new tractor.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Tregarrow Farm does not use hire purchase, and instead sells the unused land and pays the cash price.
Hire purchase has clear benefits. The farm has only £9 500 in the bank, so it could not pay £68 000 at once, but it could afford the £8 000 deposit. The new tractor would arrive straight away, so the farm would avoid more breakdowns like the one that cost it a £2 400 penalty, protecting its contract with the food processor. It would also keep its 12 hectares of land for future growth.
However, hire purchase is expensive. The farm would pay £77 600 in total, which is £9 600, or 14.1%, more than the cash price. More importantly, the payments of £1 450 a month (£17 400 a year) must be made every month for four years, but most of the farm's cash comes in between August and November. In the spring and summer the farm could struggle to make the payments and might need an overdraft, adding more interest. If it missed payments, the dealer could take the tractor back, leaving the farm unable to harvest. The agreement also lasts four years, while the contract that provides much of its income has only three years left.
Selling the land avoids these problems. The £70 000 offer covers the full £68 000 price with £2 000 to spare, there is no interest, and the farm owns the tractor immediately. The land earns nothing at the moment, so selling it does not reduce the farm's income. The drawback is that the land cannot easily be bought back if the farm wants to grow.
Overall, selling the land is the better option, because it turns an unused asset into a vital one with no extra cost and no monthly payments that clash with the farm's seasonal cash flow. This depends on the partners having no firm plans to use the land in the next few years; if they did, hire purchase would be worth the extra £9 600.