Item A
Cadno Leather
Ffion has run Cadno Leather as a sole trader for five years from a small unit in Aberystwyth. She makes handmade leather dog collars and leads, which she sells through her website and at country shows. Customers like the fact that every collar can be personalised with the dog's name, and her sales have grown every year.
A chain of 30 pet shops has offered Ffion a contract to stock her products. To supply the chain she needs £40 000 to move into a larger workshop, buy a leather-cutting machine and employ two workers. She would have to sign a five-year lease on the workshop. Her bank has offered her a loan for the full £40 000, but only if she uses her house as security.
Ffion's accountant has suggested that she turns the business into a private limited company. Ffion's parents have offered to invest £25 000 in return for 25% of the shares, and Ffion would own the other 75%. She would then only need to borrow £15 000. Ffion would be a director and take a salary, and the company would pay dividends to its shareholders out of its profit. The company's accounts would have to be published, so anyone could see them. Ffion is also worried about sharing decisions with her parents, who think she should stop selling at country shows.
Ffion expects that next year, with the pet shop contract, the business would have sales revenue of £180 000 and total costs of £126 000, including her salary. She plans to pay half of the profit to the shareholders as dividends and keep the rest in the business.
Recommend whether Ffion should turn Cadno Leather into a private limited company.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Ffion should turn Cadno Leather into a private limited company.
The main reason is limited liability. To supply the pet shop chain, Ffion must sign a five-year lease on a larger workshop and borrow money. As a sole trader she has unlimited liability, and the bank will only lend her the full £40 000 if she uses her house as security. If the pet shop contract ended early and the business could not pay its debts, she could lose her home. As a private limited company, debts such as the lease would belong to the company, so Ffion's personal losses would be limited to the money she had invested.
Becoming a company would also make the finance easier. Her parents would invest £25 000 by buying shares, so she would only need to borrow £15 000. This means smaller loan repayments and less interest, leaving more cash to pay the two new workers and buy the cutting machine.
However, there are drawbacks. Ffion would no longer receive all of the profit. If next year's profit is £54 000 and half is paid as dividends, her parents would receive £6 750, money she would keep as a sole trader. Her parents would also have a say in decisions, and they already want her to stop selling at country shows, which may be an important way of meeting customers and taking personalised orders. The company's accounts would be published, so rivals could see how well she is doing.
On balance, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. Ffion would keep 75% of the shares, so she could still outvote her parents on any major decision, and protecting her house from the risks of a five-year lease and a large new contract matters more than £6 750 of dividends. The decision depends on how reliable the pet shop contract is: if it were small or short-term, she could stay a sole trader and grow more slowly with less risk.
Explanation
Level 3 answers apply the features of a private limited company to Ffion's situation - limited liability against the five-year lease and the house used as security, the £25 000 from shares, the loss of £6 750 in dividends and her parents' influence - and reach a justified recommendation. Recognising that Ffion keeps 75% of the shares, and so majority control, is a mark of a strong answer. A list of the features of limited companies without reference to Cadno Leather cannot go above Level 2.