Item C
Thistle & Tide Ltd
Thistle & Tide Ltd makes natural skincare products, such as face creams, cleansers and lip balms, in a small factory in Aberdeen. It sells them through its website and through 85 independent gift shops and chemists across Scotland and the north of England. Almost all of its customers are women aged 25 to 55. Its products are known for their seaweed ingredients and recyclable glass jars, and they sell for £14 to £22 each. Revenue grew from £1.2 million in 2024 to £1.5 million in 2026.
The marketing director, Isla, wants to launch a range of men's skincare products. The UK market for men's skincare is growing quickly, but it is dominated by large brands sold in supermarkets for £5 to £10 a product. Developing the range, designing new packaging and running a launch campaign would cost £38 000.
Isla asked a market research agency to survey 500 men aged 18 to 60. Table 1 shows some of the results. The agency also reported that most of the men surveyed bought skincare products in supermarkets or online, not in gift shops, and that many said they did not want products that take a lot of time to use. Isla's first idea was a men's range of five products: a cleanser, a toner, a face cream, an eye cream and a lip balm, each priced at £16.
Recommend whether Thistle & Tide Ltd should launch the men's skincare range.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
There are good reasons to launch a men's range. The market is growing quickly, and Thistle & Tide currently sells almost only to women, so a men's range would give it a new source of revenue and spread its risk. The survey shows that 41% of men would consider buying a natural skincare brand, so its seaweed ingredients and recyclable jars could make it stand out from the large supermarket brands. With revenue of £1.5 million, growing by 25% in two years, the £38 000 launch cost is affordable.
However, Isla's first idea does not meet men's needs. She plans five products at £16 each, but 63% of men prefer one all-in-one product and only 17% would pay more than £12 for a face cream. Many men want skincare that is quick to use, and most buy it in supermarkets or online, not in the gift shops where Thistle & Tide sells most of its products. Large brands are sold for £5 to £10 in supermarkets, so a £16 product in gift shops would be competing in the wrong place at the wrong price. If the range did not sell, most of the £38 000 would be wasted.
I recommend that Thistle & Tide should launch a men's range, but not the one Isla first planned. It should use the research to change the marketing mix: a single all-in-one natural product, priced as close to £12 as its costs allow, sold through its website first. This targets the 41% who like natural brands without taking on the supermarket brands head-on. Launching online first would also act as a trial: if sales are good, it could add more products or try to sell through supermarkets. The decision depends on whether the business can make a profit at a lower price, so it should check its costs before launching.
Explanation
The best answers use Table 1 on both sides, for example the 41% interested in natural brands against the 63% who want an all-in-one product and the 17% who would pay over £12. A strong recommendation explains how identifying men's needs should change the range, price and place, rather than simply saying yes or no. One-sided answers, or answers that do not use the survey data, cannot reach Level 3.