Item A
Pebblebrook Candle Co.
Sasha set up Pebblebrook Candle Co. as a sole trader two years ago. She makes scented soy candles by hand in a small rented workshop in Harrogate, North Yorkshire, and sells them through her own website and an online marketplace for £12 each. Her fixed costs include the workshop rent, website fees and insurance. Her variable costs are the wax, fragrance oil, glass jar and packaging for each candle.
Figure 1 shows Pebblebrook's monthly break-even chart. Sasha currently sells about 500 candles a month. Working alone, she can make at most about 700 candles a month.
Several new candle sellers have appeared on the online marketplace, many charging £9 or £10 for similar candles. Sasha is considering cutting her price to £10. At £10 a candle, Pebblebrook would break even at 400 candles a month. Sasha asked 80 of her regular customers whether they would buy more candles at the lower price, and from their answers she estimates that sales would rise to about 650 candles a month. She calculates that her profit would then be about £1 500 a month.
Pebblebrook's candles have excellent online reviews, and customers often mention that they are hand-poured and sold in plastic-free packaging. Sasha is worried that a lower price might make her candles seem less special.
Sasha wants to compete with the new, cheaper candle sellers.
Recommend whether Sasha should cut the price of her candles from £12 to £10. Give reasons for your recommendation. Use the financial information provided to support your answer.
Model answer
I recommend that Sasha does not cut her price to £10.
Figure 1 shows that at £12 Pebblebrook breaks even at 300 candles a month. At her current sales of 500 candles, total revenue is £6 000 and total costs are £4 400, so she makes a profit of £1 600 a month, with a margin of safety of 200 candles. If she cut the price to £10, each candle would bring in £2 less, so the total revenue line would be less steep and the break-even output would rise to 400 candles a month.
Sasha estimates that sales would rise to 650 candles at £10, but even then her profit would be about £1 500 a month, £100 less than now. She would have to make 150 more candles every month, which means more hours of work for less profit. Because she can make at most about 700 candles a month, she would be working close to her limit and would struggle to meet extra demand at busy times such as Christmas.
The estimate is also risky. It is based on asking 80 regular customers, who already buy at £12 and may be keener than new customers would be. If sales rose by less than she expects, her profit would be even lower.
There is a case for cutting the price. If her estimate is right, the margin of safety would rise from 200 to 250 candles, and the new sellers charging £9 or £10 could take some of her customers if she stays at £12. However, Pebblebrook's customers praise the hand-poured candles and plastic-free packaging, which suggests that they buy for quality rather than price. A lower price could make the candles seem less special, as Sasha fears.
Overall, Sasha should keep her price at £12 and promote what makes her candles different, such as the plastic-free packaging and her excellent reviews. The price cut would mean more work for less profit, and it would only make sense if her sales at £12 started to fall well below 500 candles a month.