Item A
Kittiwake Chocolate Ltd
Kittiwake Chocolate Ltd makes handmade chocolates in Alnwick, Northumberland. Its chocolate bars and gift boxes, decorated with drawings of seabirds, are sold in its own shop, in 40 UK gift shops and through its website. Sales in the UK have grown slowly over the last two years, and the UK market for luxury chocolate is very competitive.
A chain of 25 delicatessens in Germany has offered to stock Kittiwake's gift boxes. Its buyer was impressed by the quality and designs, but wants the packaging printed in German. The chain would pay Kittiwake in euros, at a price in euros that would be fixed for the first year.
To export to Germany, Kittiwake would need to redesign its packaging and pay for temperature-controlled delivery. Table 1 shows the managing director's forecast for the first year.
Over the last two years the value of the pound against the euro has changed by up to 5% in either direction. Kittiwake's finance manager is worried that, because the price in euros would be fixed, a rise in the value of the pound would mean Kittiwake receives fewer pounds for each box. Kittiwake has never exported before, and its small office team would need to spend time on the paperwork for exporting.
Recommend whether Kittiwake should accept the offer to sell its gift boxes in Germany.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Kittiwake should accept the offer from the German chain.
The offer gives Kittiwake access to a new market at a time when its UK sales are growing only slowly and the UK luxury chocolate market is very competitive. Selling in 25 delicatessens in Germany would spread its risk across two markets, and the buyer already values its quality and designs, so the boxes are likely to sell. Table 1 forecasts revenue of £96 000 and a profit of £22 000 in the first year, a margin of about 23%. The £8 000 packaging redesign is a one-off cost, so if sales continue at the same level, profit in the second year could be about £30 000.
However, there are risks. The price in euros would be fixed for a year, so if the value of the pound rose by 5%, as it has done in the past, Kittiwake would receive about 5% fewer pounds, roughly £4 500 less revenue. As its costs are in pounds, this would cut the expected profit by about a fifth. Exporting is also new to Kittiwake: the paperwork will take up the time of its small office team, and temperature-controlled delivery costs £14 000. If the forecast is too optimistic, the profit could be much smaller than £22 000.
On balance, the benefits outweigh the risks. Even with a 5% rise in the pound, Kittiwake would still expect a profit of over £17 000 in the first year, and the exchange rate could just as easily move in its favour. The decision depends on how accurate the sales forecast is and how much time exporting takes, so Kittiwake should check that the chain plans to order regularly and agree the euro price carefully before signing.