Item A
Coombe Valley Plants
Coombe Valley Plants is a garden centre near Totnes in Devon, run as a partnership by Ruth and her son Tom. It grows many of its own plants and is known for the expert advice its staff give customers. Last year its revenue was £640 000, but sales are very seasonal: most come in spring and summer, and about a third of customers are tourists who cannot carry large plants home.
Tom wants to set up an e-commerce website to sell plants to customers anywhere in the UK. A web designer has quoted £18 000 to build the website, plus £250 a month to run it. Tom forecasts 3 000 online orders in the first year, with an average order value of £35. Plants would need special boxes so that they arrive undamaged, and delivery would cost Coombe Valley about £8.50 per order.
Ruth is less sure. Several large online plant sellers already deliver free on orders over £40, and she thinks Coombe Valley's customers come for the advice, not just the plants. Plants that arrive damaged would have to be replaced free of charge. She also points out that the business would need to employ an extra worker to pick and pack orders, and that online customers would expect quick replies to emails and social media messages, seven days a week.
Tom believes the website would help the business through the quiet winter months and would let people who visit on holiday keep buying from Coombe Valley after they go home.
Recommend whether Coombe Valley Plants should set up an e-commerce website to sell its plants across the UK.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Coombe Valley should set up the e-commerce website, but start carefully.
The main benefit is access to a wider market. At the moment the garden centre can only sell to people who visit, and about a third of its customers are tourists who cannot carry large plants home. A website would let these customers keep buying after they go home and would reach gardeners anywhere in the UK. Tom forecasts 3 000 orders at £35, which is £105 000 of extra revenue, a 16.41% increase on last year's £640 000. Online sales would also help in the quiet winter months, because customers can order at any time of the day or year, which would make the business's revenue and cash flow more even.
However, the costs are high. The website costs £18 000 plus £250 a month, so £21 000 in the first year, and delivery at £8.50 per order would cost £25 500, almost a quarter of the value of each order. Together these take £46 500 of the £105 000, before paying for the plants, the special boxes, the extra worker and replacing damaged plants. Competition is also strong: large online sellers deliver free on orders over £40, so Coombe Valley may have to keep its delivery charges low, cutting its profit further. And if customers really come for the expert advice, online shoppers may see it as just another plant seller.
On balance, I would still go ahead, because the website gives Coombe Valley a way to reach customers it is losing now and to smooth out its seasonal sales. It could use digital communication to keep its advantage, for example by putting advice videos on the website and answering questions by live chat. The decision depends on whether Tom's forecast is realistic and how many plants arrive damaged, so testing the website with a smaller range of easy-to-post plants first would reduce the risk.
Explanation
A top-level answer uses the case figures to weigh the wider market and extra revenue against the costs of delivery, the website and damaged plants. It reaches a clear recommendation and explains what the decision depends on, such as the accuracy of the forecast. Answers that only list general benefits of e-commerce, such as 'open 24/7', without applying them to Coombe Valley stay at Level 2 or below.