Item A
Tala Jewellery
Tala is a sole trader who makes handmade silver jewellery in a small workshop in Cardiff. She sells through her own website and at craft markets. Her rings, earrings and necklaces sell for £35 to £90, and her customers are mainly people aged 18 to 30 buying gifts.
Over the past two years, unemployment in the area where most of her customers live has fallen and many local employers have raised wages. Tala's sales have grown by 20% in that time.
Tala is considering launching a range of gold engagement and wedding rings priced from £450 to £1 200. To do this she would need to spend £9 000 on gold, tools and marketing. She would use £5 000 of her savings and take out a bank loan for the rest, at a fixed interest rate of 8% a year. A gold ring takes three times as long to make as a silver piece, so she would make fewer silver items.
Tala carried out a survey of 200 of her customers. The results are shown in Table 1.
A friend who runs a gift shop has warned her: 'If the economy slows down, expensive items like gold rings are the first things people stop buying.'
Recommend whether Tala should launch the range of gold rings.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Tala should launch the gold ring range, but carefully.
The economic climate supports the launch. Unemployment in the area where most of her customers live has fallen and many employers have raised wages, so customers have more disposable income. Her sales have grown by 20% in two years, and 59% of the customers she surveyed (118 out of 200) say their income has risen, while 42% plan to spend more on gifts next year. Gold engagement and wedding rings at £450 to £1 200 are luxury purchases, and demand for luxuries rises most when incomes rise. Her £4 000 loan is at a fixed 8%, so the interest is only about £320 a year and will not rise.
However, there are risks. Only 36 of the 200 customers (18%) would consider buying a gold ring from her, and 102 (51%) said no. Her customers are mainly 18 to 30 year olds buying gifts at £35 to £90, so the gold range is a big jump in price. As her friend warns, if the economy slows and unemployment rises, expensive items such as gold rings are the first purchases people cut, which would leave Tala with £9 000 spent on gold, tools and marketing and a loan to repay. Gold rings also take three times as long to make, so she would make fewer silver pieces, which are her proven sellers.
On balance, she should launch the range because incomes are rising now, and even a small number of sales at £450 to £1 200 would bring in far more than the same number of silver pieces. The decision depends on how long the good economic conditions last, so she should start with a small range, make rings to order where possible and keep making silver pieces, so that she does not rely too heavily on a luxury product.
Explanation
Top answers link the economic climate to demand: rising employment and wages increase disposable income, and demand for luxury items such as gold rings rises most. They use the survey data, such as the 18% who are interested and the 59% whose incomes have risen, and weigh the risk that an economic slowdown would hit expensive items first. A recommendation either way can reach Level 3 if it is justified with Tala's information.