Item A
Lumen Cosmetics Ltd
Lumen Cosmetics Ltd is a private limited company in Manchester that makes vegan skincare products. It sells online through its own website and social media, mainly to customers aged 18-30 who care about the environment. Lumen has three shareholders: its founder, Priya, and two friends who each invested £20 000 in the business in 2022. Last year Lumen made a net profit of £52 000 and paid its first dividend.
In March, Lumen changed the packaging of its best-selling moisturiser from glass jars to plastic tubes, saving 45p per item. Within weeks, hundreds of customers posted complaints on social media saying that the change went against Lumen's eco-friendly brand image. A beauty blogger with 250 000 followers posted a video criticising the change. Lumen's average customer rating fell from 4.8 to 3.9 stars, and its monthly online sales fell from £38 000 to £31 500.
Priya now wants to move all of Lumen's products into refillable glass jars. Customers would buy a jar once and then buy refill pouches, which would be cheaper than buying a new product each time. The change would cost £14 000 to set up and would add 60p to the cost of each item. A rival brand that offers refills has seen its sales grow by 30% this year.
The other two shareholders are against the idea. They think that customers will soon forget the complaints, and that the £14 000 should be paid out as dividends instead.
Explain one way Lumen's customers have influenced the business.
You should use the information in Item A in your answer.
Model answer
Lumen's customers have influenced the business by complaining publicly about its packaging. When the moisturiser moved from glass to plastic, hundreds of customers posted complaints on social media and a blogger with 250 000 followers criticised the change. This damaged Lumen's eco-friendly brand image, and its rating fell from 4.8 to 3.9 stars, which puts off new online customers. As a result, monthly sales fell from £38 000 to £31 500, a fall of £6 500. This pressure has forced Priya to rethink the decision, and she now wants to spend £14 000 moving all products into refillable glass jars.
Explanation
The top level needs a clear chain from the customers' action (complaints, reviews, buying less) to its effect on Lumen (a lower rating, sales down £6 500 a month, a possible change of packaging). Quoting the case figures shows application. Describing what customers want without showing how they changed Lumen's decisions or performance stays in Level 1.