Item C
Wrenmere Cottages Ltd
Wrenmere Cottages Ltd owns 12 holiday cottages near the north Norfolk coast, which it lets to holidaymakers by the week. The cottages are comfortable but simply furnished, and they are mainly booked by families on middle incomes. The average price is £950 per week, and each cottage is booked for an average of 38 weeks a year. The company has a good reputation and many families return every summer.
The managing director, Priya, wants to increase profit. She is considering converting four of the cottages into luxury cottages aimed at customers on high incomes. Each would have a hot tub, designer furniture and the option of a private chef. The price would be £2 200 per week.
Priya has found the following information:
- converting the four cottages would cost £180 000, which would be paid for with a bank loan
- running a luxury cottage costs about £10 000 a year more than running a standard cottage, mainly for extra cleaning and hot tub maintenance
- luxury holiday cottages in the area are booked for an average of 34 weeks a year
- spending on holidays by people on high incomes has stayed steady over the past two years, while many families on middle incomes have cut back
- there are already six luxury cottages within five miles, owned by two other businesses.
Some regular customers have told Priya that they would be disappointed if fewer standard cottages were available during the school summer holidays.
Recommend whether Wrenmere Cottages Ltd should convert four of its cottages to target customers on high incomes.
Give reasons for your recommendation. Use the information in Item C to support your answer.
Model answer
I recommend that Wrenmere Cottages Ltd should convert the four cottages to target customers on high incomes.
The figures suggest the luxury cottages would earn much more. A standard cottage earns 38 weeks × £950 = £36 100 a year, but a luxury cottage booked for the local average of 34 weeks at £2 200 would earn £74 800. That is £38 700 more per cottage, or £28 700 after the extra £10 000 running costs. Across four cottages this is about £114 800 extra a year, so the £180 000 conversion could be paid back in less than two years, even before allowing for loan interest. High-income customers are also a more reliable segment at present: their holiday spending has stayed steady, while many families on middle incomes have cut back, so the change would make Wrenmere less dependent on a group whose spending is falling.
There are risks. The £180 000 would be borrowed, so Wrenmere must pay interest and repay the loan even if bookings are poor. There are already six luxury cottages within five miles, and Wrenmere's reputation is for simple family cottages, so it may not reach 34 weeks of bookings at first. Some regular families would be disappointed by fewer standard cottages in the summer holidays, and losing these loyal customers could damage the good reputation that brings them back every year.
On balance, the benefits outweigh the risks. Even if each luxury cottage were booked for only 25 weeks, it would earn £55 000, which is still £8 900 more than a standard cottage after the extra running costs. Wrenmere would also keep eight standard cottages for its regular families. The decision depends on how quickly the new cottages can build a reputation against the six existing rivals, so Priya could reduce the risk by converting two cottages first and converting the others if bookings reach the local average.