Item C
Bramblewick Garden Centre
Bramblewick Garden Centre Ltd is a family-owned garden centre near Lincoln. It sells plants, garden furniture and tools, and has a café. At the start of 2025 its directors set four objectives for the year. Table 1 shows these objectives and the garden centre's results.
In March 2025 Bramblewick launched a loyalty card, which gives members 10% off plants and a free hot drink each month. Launching and running the scheme cost £30 000 in 2025, including the discounts. The managers believe the card has encouraged many regular customers to visit more often, and the café now has a waiting list for tables at weekends.
The year was difficult in other ways. A very wet spring meant fewer visitors in April and May, which are usually the busiest months for plant sales. In the summer two large DIY stores nearby cut the price of garden furniture by up to 30%, and Bramblewick's furniture sales fell. Its costs also rose, because the price of energy for its heated greenhouses increased.
The directors must now decide whether 2025 was a successful year.
Evaluate whether 2025 was a successful year for Bramblewick Garden Centre. Use the information in Item C to support your answer.
Model answer
Overall, I think 2025 was a successful year for Bramblewick, even though it missed both of its financial objectives.
Judged on its financial objectives, Bramblewick was not successful. Table 1 shows that sales revenue rose from £2 400 000 to £2 568 000, an increase of 7%, just below its objective of 8%. Net profit fell from £192 000 to £180 000, a fall of 6.25%, when the objective was a 5% increase. However, many of the reasons were outside the directors' control. A very wet spring kept visitors away in April and May, the busiest months for plant sales, two large DIY stores cut the price of garden furniture by up to 30%, and energy prices for the heated greenhouses rose. Raising revenue by 7% despite these problems suggests the business performed well.
Bramblewick met both of its other objectives, which shows that success can be measured in other ways than profit. The customer satisfaction score rose from 78% to 89%, above the target of at least 85%, and 6 200 customers joined the loyalty card scheme, beating the target of 5 000. Customers seem happier and more loyal: regular customers are visiting more often and the café has a waiting list at weekends.
The loyalty card also explains much of the fall in profit, because it cost £30 000 in 2025. Without this cost, net profit would have been £210 000, more than 9% higher than in 2024 and above the 5% target. So the lower profit partly reflects an investment that should bring repeat sales in future years.
How successful 2025 really was depends on whether the loyalty members keep spending in 2026 and whether the DIY stores keep their prices low. On balance, because Bramblewick grew its sales and its customers' loyalty in a difficult year, it was successful, but the directors should watch profit closely.
Explanation
Level 3 answers judge success against all four objectives in Table 1, recognising that success can be measured in other ways than profit, and explain the results using the case, such as the weather, the DIY stores' price cuts and the £30 000 loyalty card cost. Working out the 7% revenue increase and the 6.25% fall in profit shows good use of the data. Accept either judgement, but it must be justified rather than just stated.