Item A
Willowmere Landscapes
Ravi runs Willowmere Landscapes, a garden design and landscaping business near Norwich, as a sole trader. He employs two staff and builds patios, ponds and new gardens for homeowners. Customers pay in full when a job is finished.
The business is very seasonal. Most gardens are built between April and September, and winter work is mostly small repairs. Last year the business made a net profit of £34 000, but Ravi's bank balance always falls in the early part of the year, when he still has to pay his staff and buy plants and materials for the spring jobs. Table 1 shows his cash flow forecast for January to March. Figures in brackets are negative.
Ravi already has jobs worth £18 000 booked for April and May. He does not currently have an overdraft. His bank has offered him one with a limit of £2 500. Interest would be charged at 19% a year on the amount overdrawn, and there is an arrangement fee of £60. The bank can reduce or cancel the overdraft at any time.
Ravi's brother has suggested that, instead, Ravi should ask customers to pay a deposit of 20% when they book a job. None of the other landscapers in the area asks for a deposit. Ravi could also ask his plant nursery to give him 60 days to pay instead of 30, although it has refused to do this in the past. A wet spring could delay the start of the jobs booked for April.
In Table 1, X is the net cash flow for March and Y is the closing balance for March.
Recommend whether Ravi should arrange the overdraft to deal with the cash flow problem shown in Table 1.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Ravi arranges the overdraft.
Table 1 shows that the bank balance is forecast to fall from £1 500 at the start of January to (£1 000) at the end of February and (£1 900) at the end of March. This is because Ravi still has to pay his staff and buy plants and materials for the spring, while customers only pay when a job is finished. Without finance he could not pay his staff or suppliers in February and March.
The overdraft limit of £2 500 covers the largest shortfall of £1 900. The problem is short-term and seasonal: most gardens are built between April and September, Ravi already has £18 000 of jobs booked for April and May, and the business made a net profit of £34 000 last year. As interest is only charged on the amount overdrawn, the cost is small: one month overdrawn by £1 900 at 19% a year costs about £30, plus the £60 fee. Once customers pay in April and May, Ravi can repay the overdraft quickly.
There are risks. The limit leaves only £600 to spare in March, and if a wet spring delays the April jobs, the balance could fall below (£2 500). The bank could also reduce or cancel the overdraft at any time. Asking customers for a 20% deposit would bring in £3 600 on the jobs already booked, more than the shortfall, with no interest. However, no other landscaper asks for a deposit, so some customers might go to competitors, which would reduce Ravi's cash inflows in his busiest months. The nursery has also refused longer credit before, so that option is uncertain.
Overall, the overdraft is the best choice because it is cheap, flexible and covers the forecast shortfall without risking customers. It depends on the spring jobs starting on time, so Ravi should also ask the nursery again for 60 days' credit, to give himself more room if the weather delays his work.