Item C
Paws & Crumbs
Nia is a veterinary nurse in Swansea who earns £26 000 a year. Two years ago she began baking natural dog treats in her kitchen and selling them at weekend farmers' markets under the name Paws & Crumbs. She now sells about 600 packs a month at £4.50 each. Each pack costs her £1.60 to make and package, and she pays £180 a month for her market stalls. Customers often leave five-star reviews on her social media page, and many come back every week.
A chain of 12 pet shops in South Wales has offered to stock Paws & Crumbs treats. It would order 2 000 packs a month and pay £3.20 a pack, 60 days after each delivery. To produce this many packs, Nia would need to give up her job, rent a small commercial kitchen for £650 a month and buy an oven and packaging equipment costing £15 000. She has savings of £9 000 and would need a bank loan for the rest. She would keep her weekend market stalls.
The market for pet treats is growing, but it is competitive. Supermarkets sell well-known brands of dog treats for about £2 a pack, and two other local bakers sell homemade treats at the same markets as Nia. The price of some of her ingredients, such as oats and peanut butter, rose by 18% last year.
Nia would continue to run Paws & Crumbs as a sole trader. She has not yet written a business plan or a cash-flow forecast.
Recommend whether Nia should give up her job to supply the pet shop chain.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
The chain's offer looks attractive. An order of 2 000 packs a month at £3.20 would bring in £6 400 a month. After ingredients and packaging of £3 200 and kitchen rent of £650, Nia would add about £2 550 a month, or about £30 600 a year, which is more than her £26 000 salary, and she would still keep her market profit. Being stocked in 12 shops would also make Paws & Crumbs known across South Wales in a market that is growing, and she would gain the independence of running her own business.
However, the risks are high. The chain pays 60 days after delivery, so Nia would have to pay about £3 850 a month for ingredients, packaging and rent for two months before she received any money from it. By then she would have spent her £9 000 savings on equipment and taken a £6 000 loan, so she could quickly run out of cash. She would also depend on one large customer: if the chain found a cheaper supplier, for example one closer to the £2 supermarket price, she would be left with kitchen rent and a loan but no salary. Her profit on each chain pack is only £1.60, compared with £2.90 at the markets, and ingredient prices rose by 18% last year, so her margin could shrink further. As a sole trader she has unlimited liability, so her personal possessions would be at risk.
I recommend that Nia should not give up her job yet. The extra income of about £4 600 a year compared with her salary is small compared with the risk of a cash-flow crisis and of losing her personal possessions. She should first write a business plan and cash-flow forecast, try to agree faster payment or a trial order with the chain, and consider forming a private limited company. If the chain agrees to a contract for at least a year, the decision would become much less risky.
Explanation
Top-level answers weigh the reward (about £2 550 a month from the chain against a £26 000 salary) against specific risks from the case, such as 60-day payment, reliance on one customer, rising ingredient costs and unlimited liability. A justified conclusion says what the decision depends on, for example a guaranteed contract or a cash-flow forecast. Either recommendation can reach Level 3 if it is supported by the evidence, but one-sided answers or answers that ignore the figures cannot.