Item A
The Lantern Escape Rooms Ltd
The Lantern Escape Rooms Ltd is a small private limited company in Nottingham, owned and run by Marcus. Groups of two to eight people pay to solve puzzles and 'escape' from a themed room within an hour. The Lantern has four rooms: two are upstairs, reached by a narrow staircase with no lift, and two are on the ground floor. The front entrance has three steps, and the ground-floor rooms have narrow doorways and puzzles that involve climbing, so wheelchair users cannot take part.
Last year The Lantern took 1 300 bookings at an average of £96 per booking and made a net profit of £41 000. The company has £37 000 in the bank.
Last month a local disability group posted a review saying that wheelchair users could not take part in any of the games. A company also cancelled a team-building booking for 12 people because one of its employees uses a wheelchair. Marcus has learned that, under the Equality Act 2010, businesses that serve the public must make 'reasonable adjustments' so that disabled customers are not put at a substantial disadvantage, although what is reasonable depends on things such as the cost and the size of the business.
Changing the existing rooms would be very expensive. Instead, Marcus is considering converting a large ground-floor storeroom into a fifth escape room designed to be fully accessible, with its own level entrance from the car park, at a cost of £28 000. He estimates that it would bring in about 250 extra bookings a year, and that it would cost £6 000 a year to run. The new room would also suit families with pushchairs and older customers who find the stairs difficult.
Recommend whether Marcus should convert the ground-floor storeroom into a fully accessible escape room.
Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Marcus should convert the storeroom into an accessible room.
The Equality Act 2010 requires businesses that serve the public to make reasonable adjustments for disabled customers. At the moment wheelchair users cannot take part at all, and this is already harming The Lantern: a local disability group has posted a critical review, and a company cancelled a team-building booking for 12 people. More bad reviews could put off many other customers, and doing nothing risks a legal claim. Because what is reasonable depends on cost and the size of the business, a £28 000 conversion may not be strictly required, but it would clearly show that The Lantern takes its duties seriously.
The conversion also makes business sense. Marcus estimates 250 extra bookings a year at an average of £96, which is about £24 000 of revenue. After running costs of £6 000, the room would add about £18 000 a year to profit, an increase of around 44% on last year's £41 000, and it would pay for itself in about a year and a half. The room would also attract families with pushchairs and older customers, and companies are more likely to book team-building events if all their staff can take part.
However, the cost is high for a small business. Spending £28 000 would leave only £9 000 in the bank, so an unexpected bill or a quiet few months could cause cash flow problems. The estimate of 250 extra bookings may also be too optimistic, as Marcus has no evidence yet of how often disabled customers or companies would book.
On balance, the benefits outweigh the risks, because the room tackles the legal and reputational problem and adds a new source of profit. The decision depends on how reliable the 250 bookings estimate is, so Marcus should ask the disability group and local companies how often they would book, and consider a small loan so that he keeps more cash in the bank.