Question 1
20 marksRead the two poems and answer the question.
Poem 1: Clearing
Most mornings, before the town wakes up,
I take the path behind the last houses,
and the traffic thins behind me
to a thread, and snaps.
Here the light comes down in pieces,
green through the beech leaves,
gold where it lands on moss
as thick as fur and soft enough to sleep on.
A woodpecker knocks at a door no one will open.
Somewhere a stream is sorting its stones.
A jay goes off like a car alarm
and settles, embarrassed.
Then the trees step back,
and there is the clearing,
a bowl of sunlight with the lid left off,
and a fallen oak to sit on.
I stay until the dew has dried on my boots,
then walk back down into the noise,
carrying the quiet with me
like a pocketful of warm stones.
Marisol Penhale (fictional)
Poem 2: The Pines
The sun slipped down behind the hill
an hour before I thought it would,
and every trunk stood straight and still
as I went hurrying through the wood.
The path I'd followed in the light
had dwindled to a ribbon, grey,
and something shifted, out of sight,
and stopped each time I turned its way.
The needles swallowed every sound.
No bird. No wind. No running stream.
Just my own heartbeat, and the ground
as soft and silent as a dream.
The pines leaned in on either side,
a thousand pillars, black and tall,
and there was nowhere left to hide
and no way out of them at all.
At last, the stile. The open lane.
The yellow windows of the farm.
I turned to face the pines again:
they stood as if they meant no harm.
Joel Haverstock (fictional)
Compare the ways the writers present a wood in Poem 1: Clearing and Poem 2: The Pines.
In your answer, you should compare:
- the ideas in the poems
- the poets' use of language
- the poets' use of form and structure.
Use evidence from the poems to support your comparison.
Model answer
Both poems take a speaker into a wood, but one finds peace there and the other finds fear. 'Clearing' describes a walk the speaker takes "Most mornings, before the town wakes up", a calm, present-tense ritual; 'The Pines' is a past-tense narrative of a hurried walk at dusk, in which the same kind of place becomes threatening. Read together, they show how much a wood depends on light, time and the state of mind of the person walking through it.
The openings establish the contrast. Penhale's speaker chooses the wood: "I take the path behind the last houses, / and the traffic thins behind me / to a thread, and snaps." The metaphor of a thread makes the last tie to the town break cleanly, and "Most mornings" shows that this escape is a routine the speaker relies on. Haverstock's speaker has no such control: "The sun slipped down behind the hill / an hour before I thought it would", and the verb "slipped" suggests that the light escaped while the speaker was not looking. The present tense of 'Clearing' captures a calm, repeated moment, while the past tense of 'The Pines' relives a frightening memory. Even the times of day are opposed: one walk begins as the day starts, the other as it ends.
Light is central to both. In 'Clearing' "the light comes down in pieces, / green through the beech leaves, / gold where it lands on moss", and the colour words make the light rich and generous; the moss is "as thick as fur and soft enough to sleep on", a simile that makes the wood feel alive, warm and safe. In 'The Pines' the light has drained away: the path "had dwindled to a ribbon, grey", and by the fourth stanza the trees are "a thousand pillars, black and tall". The movement from colour to grey to black traces the speaker's growing fear.
Both poems also listen. Penhale fills the third stanza with lively, companionable sounds, each in its own sentence: "A woodpecker knocks at a door no one will open. / Somewhere a stream is sorting its stones." Personifying the stream as sorting its stones suggests a wood busy with its own patient work, and the door that "no one will open" is gently mysterious rather than threatening. There is even comedy: "A jay goes off like a car alarm / and settles, embarrassed." The simile briefly brings the town's noise into the wood, and the jay's embarrassment makes it funny. Haverstock's stanza of sound is the opposite: "The needles swallowed every sound. / No bird. No wind. No running stream." The three short, verbless sentences, each beginning "No", form an eerie list of absences, and "swallowed" makes the forest floor seem to devour noise. Penhale's stream is busy; Haverstock's is missing, and the speaker hears only "my own heartbeat", a sign of panic.
The trees themselves behave in opposite ways. In 'Clearing' "the trees step back", and the clearing appears as "a bowl of sunlight with the lid left off, / and a fallen oak to sit on": the metaphor opens the space up to the sky, and the practical detail of a seat makes it a place to rest. In 'The Pines' "The pines leaned in on either side", closing the space down until "there was nowhere left to hide / and no way out of them at all". Both poems personify the trees, but one wood makes room for the walker and the other traps them. There is even a hint of something hunting in 'The Pines', which "stopped each time I turned its way"; the vague "something" is more frightening than any named creature.
Form supports these feelings. 'Clearing' is free verse in five unrhymed quatrains with lines of varied length, moving at the pace of an unhurried walk. 'The Pines' uses five regular quatrains rhymed ABAB ("hill" / "still", "side" / "hide") in a quick, insistent tetrameter that sounds like hurried footsteps, and its rhymes close each stanza tightly, just as the trees close in. The endings remain apart. Penhale's speaker stays "until the dew has dried on my boots", then walks "back down into the noise, / carrying the quiet with me / like a pocketful of warm stones": the simile makes calm something solid and comforting that can be carried back into ordinary life. Haverstock's speaker escapes to "The yellow windows of the farm", but the final line, "they stood as if they meant no harm", is ambiguous, because "as if" hints that the harmlessness might be a pretence. For me, 'Clearing' presents the wood as a regular refuge whose peace can be taken home, while 'The Pines' shows how quickly the same kind of place can feel like a trap when darkness falls. One speaker leaves carrying the wood's quiet; the other leaves still unsure what was watching.
Explanation
Level 5 needs a sustained comparison of the two attitudes to the wood - a calm, regular refuge in 'Clearing', fear in 'The Pines' - analysing how light, sound and the personified trees work in each and how the forms differ (present-tense free verse against a rhymed past-tense narrative). Pairing details such as the trees that "step back" with the pines that "leaned in", or the busy stream with "No running stream", is what makes the comparison perceptive. An answer on one poem only is capped at 8 marks (the top of Level 2). Weaker answers summarise each walk, or miss the ambiguity of the final line of 'The Pines'.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 (8 marks), AO2 (12 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The writing is informed by perceptive comparisons and contrasts, with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and differences between the poems considered. There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text and discerning choice of references to the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation with discerning choice of references to the text. There is perceptive grasp of form and structure and their effect. The response offers a cohesive evaluation of the poets' language and its effects on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is integrated and precise.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and differences, and ideas are supported throughout with relevant examples from both poems and contrasting a wide range of points. The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text with well-chosen references to the text. The critical style is sustained and there is well-developed interpretation with well-chosen references to the text. Analysis of form and structure and their effect is sustained. The candidate comments effectively on the poets' use of language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used accurately and appropriately to develop ideas.
Level 3 (9-12 marks), Level 2 (5-8 marks), Level 1 (1-4 marks): Pearson's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 8 if only one text is considered (Pearson's mark scheme: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE text has been considered). Pearson's grid: AO1 (8 marks) and AO2 (12 marks): in each level bullet 1 is comparison, bullets 2 and 3 are AO1 and bullets 4, 5 and 6 are AO2. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and differences between the poems. The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text with focused supporting textual references. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation with focused supporting textual references. The response shows a sound understanding of form and structure and links them to their effect. There is clear awareness, with sound examples, of how the poets use language and of its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used to support examples given. Level 2 (5-8 marks): There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and differences, supported with some ideas from the poems. The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of a personal response; there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. There is some evidence of a critical style. There is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. There is some comment on the form and structure of the poems. Some awareness of the poets' use of language is shown, but without development. Limited use of relevant subject terminology to support examples given. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE text has been considered. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is little or no comparison of the two poems. The response is simple with little personal response and little relevant supporting reference to the text. There is little evidence of a critical style and little relevant supporting reference to the text. Identification of form and structure is minimal. There is little awareness of the language used by the poets. Little evidence of relevant subject terminology. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points):
- Ideas: Poem 1 presents a walk the speaker takes "Most mornings, before the town wakes up" into a wood that brings peace, carried home afterwards "like a pocketful of warm stones"; Poem 2 recalls a hurried walk through a pine wood at dusk that becomes frightening, ending with an ambiguous "as if they meant no harm".
- Language: Poem 1 uses rich colour ("green", "gold"), a warm simile ("as thick as fur"), gentle personification ("a stream is sorting its stones", "the trees step back") and comedy (a jay "like a car alarm" that settles, "embarrassed"); Poem 2 moves from grey to black ("a ribbon, grey", "black and tall"), personifies the trees as closing in ("The pines leaned in") and uses the vague, threatening "something".
- Form and structure: Poem 1 is first-person, present-tense free verse in five unrhymed quatrains describing a calm routine; Poem 2 is a past-tense narrative in five ABAB quatrains of quick tetrameter, with a list of absences ("No bird. No wind. No running stream.").
- Comparison: morning against dusk; welcome against threat; light against darkness; busy sounds against silence and "my own heartbeat"; the trees open the space in one poem and trap the speaker in the other; one speaker takes the wood's calm home, the other escapes still uneasy. AO3 (context) is not assessed in this question (Pearson's mark scheme: AO1 8 marks, AO2 12 marks).