Question 1
20 marksRelationships
Neutral Tones
We stood by a pond that winter day,
And the sun was white, as though chidden of God,
And a few leaves lay on the starving sod;
- They had fallen from an ash, and were gray.
Your eyes on me were as eyes that rove
Over tedious riddles of years ago;
And some words played between us to and fro
On which lost the more by our love.
The smile on your mouth was the deadest thing
Alive enough to have strength to die;
And a grin of bitterness swept thereby
Like an ominous bird a-wing...
Since then, keen lessons that love deceives,
And wrings with wrong, have shaped to me
Your face, and the God-curst sun, and a tree,
And a pond edged with grayish leaves.
Thomas Hardy (1898)
Re-read Neutral Tones. Choose one other poem from the Relationships anthology.
Compare how images of death are used in the two poems.
In your answer, you should consider the:
- poets' use of language, form and structure
- influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.
The other poems in the Relationships collection are: La Belle Dame Sans Merci (John Keats); A Child to his Sick Grandfather (Joanna Baillie); She Walks in Beauty (Lord Byron); A Complaint (William Wordsworth); Sonnet 43 (Elizabeth Barrett Browning); My Last Duchess (Robert Browning); 1st Date - She and 1st Date - He (Wendy Cope); Valentine (Carol Ann Duffy); One Flesh (Elizabeth Jennings); i wanna be yours (John Cooper Clarke); Love's Dog (Jen Hadfield); Nettles (Vernon Scannell); The Manhunt (Simon Armitage); My Father Would Not Show Us (Ingrid de Kok).
Model answer
Thomas Hardy's 'Neutral Tones' and Ingrid de Kok's 'My Father Would Not Show Us' are both full of images of death, but in Hardy no one actually dies: the images express the death of a love, whereas de Kok's speaker stands beside a father who is "five days dead", and the images of death are real.
Hardy fills his landscape with dying things. The leaves "lay on the starving sod", and the personification makes the earth itself seem to waste away from hunger. The leaves "had fallen from an ash": "fallen" can also describe soldiers killed in battle, and the name of the ash tree may suggest what is left after burning. Hardy wrote the poem in 1867, when he was still in his twenties, yet its landscape already has the bleakness for which his poetry, with its dark view of love and fate, would become known. De Kok's images are literal. The speaker sees that "the borrowed coffin gleams unnaturally", and the adverb shows how strange and wrong the scene feels; the father's face is "this inverted face", made unfamiliar by death. Where Hardy turns nature into a metaphor for loss, de Kok records the physical facts of a death with painful precision.
Both poets centre their images of death on a face and a smile. Hardy's most powerful image is the smile of the person addressed: "the deadest thing / Alive enough to have strength to die". The paradox suggests a smile that still moves but has only enough life left to end, so the death of love happens in front of the speaker, in an expression. De Kok's speaker remembers "my father's wry smile", a sign of life and humour, and sets it against the face in the coffin. Hardy's smile is already dead while the person lives; de Kok's smile survives only in memory after the person has died.
Both poems also set death against something living, though in different ways. Hardy's living things are themselves dying: the sun is weak, the earth starved, the leaves fallen, and nothing grows. De Kok places death beside new growth: the florist's flowers are "curling into spring", a reminder that life continues even as the father lies dead. Her images of the father's last illness are of withdrawal - "he lay inside, he lay", "face to the wall" - so death is something he turned towards in silence, refusing to show his family "how to die". Hardy's death is a slow fading of feeling; de Kok's is a private turning away.
Form shapes the images. Hardy's four abba quatrains are tightly controlled, and their envelope rhyme encloses each stanza, so the images of death are held within a rigid frame. His circular structure brings back the tree and the "grayish leaves" in the final stanza, making the dead love permanent in memory. De Kok, by contrast, gives up regular metre and rhyme; her stanzas grow and shrink between three lines and six, and the poem slides from the body in front of the speaker to a remembered childhood and then to what the dying man himself could recall, as if death had broken time into pieces. Her repeated lines create a pattern like grief returning to the same thought.
Dated 1988 in the anthology, the poem is an early work by the South African poet, one that she later reprinted in her selected poems, Seasonal Fires (2006), and its epigraph, attributed to Rilke, asks which way we should face to talk to the dead. Hardy's dead are a feeling and a season; de Kok's is a father. Hardy uses death to describe the end of a love; de Kok must describe death itself, and finds that it, too, leaves a silence that cannot be answered.
Explanation
A Level 5 response compares how death imagery works in each poem - as an extended metaphor for the death of love in Hardy (the starving sod, the fallen leaves, the paradoxical smile), and as the literal facts of a father's death in de Kok (the coffin, the inverted face, the turning to the wall) - with precise analysis of personification, paradox and the contrasting forms, and context woven in, such as Hardy's age when he wrote the poem and de Kok's selected poems. Discussing only one poem limits the mark to 8. Avoid giving de Kok's speaker a gender, avoid saying that anyone dies in Neutral Tones, and present readings such as the ash tree's name as readings.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO2 (15 marks), AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The writing is informed by perceptive comparisons and contrasts, with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and/or differences between the poems considered. There is perceptive grasp of form and structure and their effect. The response offers a cohesive evaluation of the poets' language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is integrated and precise. There is excellent understanding of context, and convincing understanding of the relationship between poems and context is integrated into the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and/or differences, and ideas are supported throughout with relevant examples from both poems. Analysis of form and structure and their effect is sustained. The candidate comments effectively on the poets' use of language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used accurately and appropriately to develop ideas. There is sustained comment on relevant context and detailed awareness of the relationship between poems and context.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and/or differences between the poems. The response shows a sound understanding of form and structure and links them to their effect. There is clear awareness, with sound examples, of the poets' use of language and of its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used to support examples given. There is sound comment on relevant context and sound relevant comment on the relationship between poems and context.
Level 2 (5-8 marks), Level 1 (1-4 marks): Pearson's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 8 if only one poem is considered (Pearson's mark scheme: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered). Pearson's grid: AO2 (15 marks) and AO3 (5 marks): in each level bullet 1 is comparison, bullets 2, 3 and 4 are AO2 and bullet 5 is AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 2 (5-8 marks): There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and/or differences, supported with some ideas from the poems. There is some comment on the form and structure of the poems. Some awareness of the poets' use of language is shown, but without development. Limited use of relevant subject terminology to support examples given. There is some awareness of relevant context and some comment on the relationship between poems and context. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is little or no comparison of the two poems. Identification of form and structure is minimal. There is little awareness of the language used by the poets. Little evidence of relevant subject terminology. There is little awareness of context and little comment on the relationship between poems and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points):
Neutral Tones - form and structure (AO2): images of death run through every stanza though no one dies - the poem is about the death of love; the circular structure returns to the dead leaves of the opening.
Language (AO2): "the starving sod" (personified, dying earth); leaves that "had fallen from an ash" ("fallen" can also describe soldiers killed in battle; the ash tree's name may suggest what is left after burning - readings); the paradox of the smile, "the deadest thing / Alive enough to have strength to die".
Context (AO3): written in 1867, when Hardy was in his twenties; his poetry is known for a bleak view of love and fate.
Second poem: any suitable poem from the Relationships collection is credited. For example, My Father Would Not Show Us (Ingrid de Kok): literal death - the father "five days dead", "the borrowed coffin gleams unnaturally", "this inverted face"; life beside death ("curling into spring"); the father would not show "how to die"; "he lay inside, he lay"; "face to the wall"; the remembered "wry smile"; free verse with repeated lines; epigraph attributed to Rilke; context: an early poem by the South African poet, dated 1988 in the anthology and later reprinted in her selected poems, Seasonal Fires (2006).
Comparison: Hardy uses death as a metaphor for the end of love, de Kok faces a real death; both centre on a face and a smile; Hardy's images are of nature dying in winter, de Kok's set death against spring; Hardy's regular abba quatrains against de Kok's free verse. Pearson's mark schemes reward responses that compare the named poem to a substantial extent with a second poem. AO3 (5 marks) is the influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.