Question 1
20 marksConflict
The Man He Killed
'Had he and I but met
By some old ancient inn,
We should have sat us down to wet
Right many a nipperkin!
'But ranged as infantry,
And staring face to face,
I shot at him as he at me,
And killed him in his place.
'I shot him dead because -
Because he was my foe,
Just so: my foe of course he was;
That's clear enough; although
'He thought he'd 'list, perhaps,
Off-hand like - just as I -
Was out of work - had sold his traps -
No other reason why.
'Yes; quaint and curious war is!
You shoot a fellow down
You'd treat if met where any bar is,
Or help to half-a-crown.'
Thomas Hardy (1902)
Re-read The Man He Killed. Choose one other poem from the Conflict anthology.
Compare how the reasons for fighting are presented in the two poems.
In your answer, you should consider the:
- poets' use of language, form and structure
- influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.
The other poems in the Conflict collection are: A Poison Tree (William Blake); The Destruction of Sennacherib (Lord Byron); Extract from The Prelude (William Wordsworth); Cousin Kate (Christina Rossetti); Half-caste (John Agard); Exposure (Wilfred Owen); The Charge of the Light Brigade (Alfred, Lord Tennyson); Catrin (Gillian Clarke); War Photographer (Carole Satyamurti); Belfast Confetti (Ciaran Carson); The Class Game (Mary Casey); Poppies (Jane Weir); No Problem (Benjamin Zephaniah); What Were They Like? (Denise Levertov).
Model answer
Hardy's 'The Man He Killed' and Tennyson's 'The Charge of the Light Brigade' both raise the question of why soldiers fight, and both suggest that the soldiers themselves do not choose the reasons. Hardy's soldier admits that he and the man he killed probably joined up for ordinary, economic reasons and fought because they were told the other was a "foe"; Tennyson's cavalrymen charge because they are ordered to, even though "Some one had blunder'd", and the poem presents their unquestioning obedience as heroic.
Both poems use the same phrase, "reason why", but to different ends. Tennyson's second stanza states the soldiers' duty in three parallel lines: "Their's not to make reply, / Their's not to reason why, / Their's but to do and die". The anaphora and the rhyme of "reply", "why" and "die" make obedience sound like a fixed law, and the poem presents it as admirable: the soldiers do not ask for reasons. Hardy's speaker, in contrast, keeps looking for one. The speaker guesses that the man he killed enlisted "Off-hand like", because he "Was out of work - had sold his traps - / No other reason why." The phrase that in Tennyson forbids questioning becomes in Hardy a bleak admission that there was no real reason at all. Hardy dated the poem 1902 and later collected it in Time's Laughingstocks (1909), and its colloquial "'list" and "traps" place the speaker among working men for whom the army was simply a job.
The poems present the soldiers' choices differently. Tennyson's brigade acts on a command given in direct speech: "'Forward, the Light Brigade! / Charge for the guns!' he said". The officer is unnamed, and the soldiers' response is not a decision but movement: "Into the valley of Death / Rode the six hundred". Even though "the soldier knew / Some one had blunder'd", the rhetorical question "Was there a man dismay'd?" expects the answer no. Tennyson, Poet Laureate at the time, said the poem was founded on a phrase in the newspaper's report of Balaclava, that someone had blundered: a loosely worded order had sent the Light Brigade down a valley into the Russian guns in October 1854. Hardy's soldiers did make a choice, but a careless one: "He thought he'd 'list, perhaps, / Off-hand like - just as I". The casual "Off-hand like" and the hesitant "perhaps" suggest that a life-and-death decision was taken lightly, and the dashes blur the two men's reasons together.
Hardy also examines the reason the army gives for killing: the enemy is the "foe". The speaker repeats it, "Because he was my foe, / Just so: my foe of course he was; / That's clear enough", but the stiff "Just so" and "of course" show that it explains nothing, and the stanza ends on "although", which opens the doubt. Tennyson never examines the enemy at all. The Russians are simply "Cossack and Russian", who "Reel'd from the sabre-stroke", and their guns are "the jaws of Death". The soldiers' reason for fighting is loyalty to their orders and to each other, not hatred.
Writing for the nation, Tennyson admits the blunder and still turns obedience into glory: "Honour the charge they made!" Hardy's ordinary soldier concludes only that "quaint and curious war is!" Tennyson honours soldiers who do not ask why; Hardy gives a voice to one who does.
Explanation
A Level 5 answer compares the reasons for fighting throughout - orders and duty in Tennyson, poverty and an empty label in Hardy - and analyses how each poem presents them (the anaphora and rhyme of "Their's not to reason why"; Hardy's dashes, "Off-hand like" and "No other reason why"), with context woven in (the Poet Laureate and the blunder at Balaclava; Hardy's working-class soldier). Writing about one poem only limits the mark to 8. A common weakness is to call both poems anti-war without noticing that Tennyson honours the obedience Hardy questions.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO2 (15 marks), AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The writing is informed by perceptive comparisons and contrasts, with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and/or differences between the poems considered. There is perceptive grasp of form and structure and their effect. The response offers a cohesive evaluation of the poets' language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is integrated and precise. There is excellent understanding of context, and convincing understanding of the relationship between poems and context is integrated into the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and/or differences, and ideas are supported throughout with relevant examples from both poems. Analysis of form and structure and their effect is sustained. The candidate comments effectively on the poets' use of language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used accurately and appropriately to develop ideas. There is sustained comment on relevant context and detailed awareness of the relationship between poems and context.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and/or differences between the poems. The response shows a sound understanding of form and structure and links them to their effect. There is clear awareness, with sound examples, of the poets' use of language and of its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used to support examples given. There is sound comment on relevant context and sound relevant comment on the relationship between poems and context.
Level 2 (5-8 marks), Level 1 (1-4 marks): Pearson's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 8 if only one poem is considered (Pearson's mark scheme: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered). Pearson's grid: AO2 (15 marks) and AO3 (5 marks): in each level bullet 1 is comparison, bullets 2, 3 and 4 are AO2 and bullet 5 is AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 2 (5-8 marks): There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and/or differences, supported with some ideas from the poems. There is some comment on the form and structure of the poems. Some awareness of the poets' use of language is shown, but without development. Limited use of relevant subject terminology to support examples given. There is some awareness of relevant context and some comment on the relationship between poems and context. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is little or no comparison of the two poems. Identification of form and structure is minimal. There is little awareness of the language used by the poets. Little evidence of relevant subject terminology. There is little awareness of context and little comment on the relationship between poems and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): Responses may include: 'The Man He Killed' - form and structure (AO2): a dramatic monologue in which the speaker keeps searching for a reason; the third stanza ends on "although" and runs on into the fourth, where the real reasons emerge; dashes break the voice. Language (AO2): the official reason, repeated and hollow ("Because he was my foe, / Just so: my foe of course he was"); the careless choice to enlist, guessed at ("He thought he'd 'list, perhaps, / Off-hand like - just as I"); poverty ("Was out of work - had sold his traps"); "No other reason why"; "quaint and curious war is!". Context (AO3): Hardy dated the poem 1902 and collected it in Time's Laughingstocks (1909); his war poems use the colloquial voices of ordinary soldiers. Second poem: any suitable poem from the Conflict collection that allows candidates to explore the reasons for fighting is credited. For example, with 'The Charge of the Light Brigade': the order in direct speech ("Forward, the Light Brigade!"); obedience as law in the anaphora and rhyme of "Their's not to make reply, / Their's not to reason why, / Their's but to do and die"; "Some one had blunder'd"; the rhetorical question "Was there a man dismay'd?"; the enemy barely described ("Cossack and Russian"); the final commands "Honour the charge they made!"; context: Tennyson as Poet Laureate; the charge at Balaclava (October 1854) in the Crimean War after a misunderstood order; Tennyson said the poem was founded on a newspaper's phrase that someone had blundered. Comparison: both suggest the soldiers do not choose the reasons; the shared phrase "reason why" forbids questioning in Tennyson and admits there was no reason in Hardy; Tennyson honours unquestioning duty, Hardy questions it (AO3). Pearson's mark schemes reward responses that compare the named poem to a substantial extent with a second poem. AO3 (5 marks) is the influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.