Question 1
20 marksRemind yourself of 'Belfast Confetti' by Ciaran Carson from the Pearson Edexcel GCSE Poetry Anthology (the 'Conflict' collection). Choose one other poem from the Conflict anthology.
Compare how confusion is presented in the two poems.
In your answer, you should consider the:
- poets' use of language, form and structure
- influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.
The other poems in the Conflict collection are: A Poison Tree (William Blake); The Destruction of Sennacherib (Lord Byron); Extract from The Prelude (William Wordsworth); The Man He Killed (Thomas Hardy); Cousin Kate (Christina Rossetti); Half-caste (John Agard); Exposure (Wilfred Owen); The Charge of the Light Brigade (Alfred, Lord Tennyson); Catrin (Gillian Clarke); War Photographer (Carole Satyamurti); The Class Game (Mary Casey); Poppies (Jane Weir); No Problem (Benjamin Zephaniah); What Were They Like? (Denise Levertov).
Model answer
Thomas Hardy's 'The Man He Killed' and 'Belfast Confetti' both give a voice to someone who cannot make sense of what conflict has done, and both let the confusion show in broken speech. Hardy's soldier is confused afterwards, trying to explain a killing he can no longer justify; Carson's speaker is confused in the moment, inside a riot that scrambles both the streets and the mind.
Hardy's confusion grows out of a story told in an easy, pub-like voice. The speaker imagines that in peacetime he and his victim would have shared drinks, and then he reaches the killing: "I shot him dead because - / Because he was my foe". The dash breaks off the explanation at the end of the line, and the repeated "because" at the start of the next shows a mind going round in a circle, coming back to the same word without finding a reason. The same stanza closes on "although", a conjunction that promises a doubt and then hands it on to the next stanza, so the structure itself refuses to settle the argument. Hardy dated the poem 1902, the year the war between Britain and the Boer republics ended, and the muddle is that of an ordinary man asked to accept that a stranger was simply an enemy.
Carson's confusion is physical and immediate. The speaker's sentence "kept stuttering", a verb that suggests both broken speech and the rattle of gunfire, so the confusion in the head and the noise in the street become one. The poem stutters too: "Nuts, bolts, nails, car-keys" lists objects without a verb, as if the speaker can only name things as they fly past, not connect them. A burst of shooting even turns into a remark about writing - "This hyphenated line" - so that the reader cannot tell whether the line is gunfire or the line of verse being read. Carson grew up in a home where Irish was spoken, and this poem about his own city in the Troubles, which the anthology dates 1990, is unusually alert to the way language comes apart.
The forms show where each confusion stands. Hardy writes in short quatrains rhyming abab, the shape of a ballad or a tale told over a drink, and the regular pattern suggests a speaker trying to keep his story tidy; the dashes in the middle stanzas break it exactly where his reasoning fails. Carson has no rhyme to hold on to. His nine long lines are chopped by full stops into fragments, so the form has already fallen apart before the speaker can try to order anything. Hardy's confusion pushes against an orderly form; Carson's has broken it.
The objects of confusion differ as well. Hardy's speaker knows exactly where he was; what he cannot grasp is why. His closing logic is painfully plain: "You shoot a fellow down" whom "You'd treat if met where any bar is". Setting the two halves of the same man side by side exposes the absurdity, and the verdict "quaint and curious war is!" uses adjectives so mild that they sound like a shrug. Carson's speaker, by contrast, knows "this labyrinth so well" yet cannot find a way out of it: "Where am I going?" comes in a run of questions the poem never answers, and because no side is named, even who is fighting whom stays unclear.
Both poems therefore end in confusion rather than understanding. Hardy's soldier can only shrug at a war that made him kill a man like himself; Carson's speaker is left with questions in a city that has turned into a maze. Conflict, in each, takes away the ability to make sense - long afterwards for one speaker, and in the very moment for the other.
Explanation
Level 5 answers compare how each poet makes broken speech show confusion - Hardy's dash and repeated "because", the stanza ending on "although"; Carson's stuttering sentence, verbless list and double-edged "hyphenated line" - and the different objects of confusion (why I killed; where I am). Context should explain each speaker: an ordinary soldier at the end of the Boer War, and a Belfast riot in the Troubles. One-poem answers are capped at 8, and listing devices without comparing them stays in the lower levels.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO2 (15 marks), AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The writing is informed by perceptive comparisons and contrasts, with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and/or differences between the poems considered. There is perceptive grasp of form and structure and their effect. The response offers a cohesive evaluation of the poets' language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is integrated and precise. There is excellent understanding of context, and convincing understanding of the relationship between poems and context is integrated into the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and/or differences, and ideas are supported throughout with relevant examples from both poems. Analysis of form and structure and their effect is sustained. The candidate comments effectively on the poets' use of language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used accurately and appropriately to develop ideas. There is sustained comment on relevant context and detailed awareness of the relationship between poems and context.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and/or differences between the poems. The response shows a sound understanding of form and structure and links them to their effect. There is clear awareness, with sound examples, of the poets' use of language and of its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used to support examples given. There is sound comment on relevant context and sound relevant comment on the relationship between poems and context.
Level 2 (5-8 marks), Level 1 (1-4 marks): Pearson's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 8 if only one poem is considered (Pearson's mark scheme: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered). Pearson's grid: AO2 (15 marks) and AO3 (5 marks): in each level bullet 1 is comparison, bullets 2, 3 and 4 are AO2 and bullet 5 is AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 2 (5-8 marks): There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and/or differences, supported with some ideas from the poems. There is some comment on the form and structure of the poems. Some awareness of the poets' use of language is shown, but without development. Limited use of relevant subject terminology to support examples given. There is some awareness of relevant context and some comment on the relationship between poems and context. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is little or no comparison of the two poems. Identification of form and structure is minimal. There is little awareness of the language used by the poets. Little evidence of relevant subject terminology. There is little awareness of context and little comment on the relationship between poems and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): Belfast Confetti - form and structure (AO2): nine long lines broken into fragments and verbless lists; the second stanza ends in unanswered questions. Language (AO2): the speaker's sentence "kept stuttering"; the jumbled list "Nuts, bolts, nails, car-keys"; "This hyphenated line", which could be gunfire or the line of verse; "Where am I going?". Context (AO3): a riot in Belfast during the Troubles; Carson grew up in a home where Irish was spoken and is acutely aware of language; the poem takes no side (the anthology dates it 1990). Any suitable second poem is credited. For example, with The Man He Killed: the circling explanation "I shot him dead because - / Because he was my foe"; a stanza ending on "although" that runs on; the plain logic of "You shoot a fellow down" whom "You'd treat if met where any bar is"; the mild verdict "quaint and curious war is!"; abab quatrains told in one soldier's voice; Hardy dates the poem 1902, the year the Boer War ended. Comparison: confusion afterwards v in the moment; moral confusion about killing v confusion of place and identity; dashes in a regular ballad-like form v full stops in long free-verse lines. Pearson's mark schemes reward responses that compare the named poem to a substantial extent with a second poem. AO3 (5 marks) is the influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.