Question 1
20 marksRemind yourself of 'The Manhunt' by Simon Armitage from the Pearson Edexcel GCSE Poetry Anthology (the 'Relationships' collection). Choose one other poem from the Relationships anthology.
Compare how silence is presented in the two poems.
In your answer, you should consider the:
- poets' use of language, form and structure
- influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.
The other poems in the Relationships collection are: La Belle Dame Sans Merci (John Keats); A Child to his Sick Grandfather (Joanna Baillie); She Walks in Beauty (Lord Byron); A Complaint (William Wordsworth); Neutral Tones (Thomas Hardy); Sonnet 43 (Elizabeth Barrett Browning); My Last Duchess (Robert Browning); 1st Date - She and 1st Date - He (Wendy Cope); Valentine (Carol Ann Duffy); One Flesh (Elizabeth Jennings); i wanna be yours (John Cooper Clarke); Love's Dog (Jen Hadfield); Nettles (Vernon Scannell); My Father Would Not Show Us (Ingrid de Kok).
Model answer
Simon Armitage's 'The Manhunt' and Joanna Baillie's 'A Child to his Sick Grandfather' both present a silent man cared for by someone who loves him, but the child in Baillie's poem fills the silence with talk, questions and stories, while Armitage's speaker meets the man's silence without words, through patient touch.
Armitage's man never speaks. Not a word of his is recorded in the poem, and even his jaw is a "blown hinge", an image of a mouth that can no longer open and close as it should. Permission is given, but silently: the repeated "would he let me" shows that he allows the speaker closer, step by step, without the poem ever saying how. The poem was first heard in a 2007 television documentary, The Not Dead, in which former soldiers read Armitage's poems based on their own accounts, and that origin makes the silence significant: the poem gives a voice to experience that the man in it cannot put into words.
Baillie's poem is the opposite: it is all speech. The child addresses the grandfather throughout, asking "You will not die and leave us then?", promising "I'll sit and talk with you", and offering stories, "a tale both long and good", about a hen and a fox and knights in armour. Yet the grandfather's silence grows as the child talks. "You nod, I think?" the child asks, unsure, and then sees that "Your fixed eyes begin to wink"; the poem ends with the realisation, "You do not hear me, dad." The dash before that last line marks the moment when talk meets a silence it cannot break.
The causes of silence differ. Baillie's grandfather is silenced by age and illness; his "stocked legs begin to fail", and sleep or weakness carries him away from the child's voice. Armitage's man is silenced by trauma. The worst damage is an "unexploded mine" in his mind, around which every nerve has "tightened and closed", so his silence is a kind of self-protection, a way of keeping the dangerous memory shut in. Baillie's household also makes a protective silence of its own: "We'll doff our shoes and softly tread", and the neighbours kneel to pray. Baillie, the daughter of a Church of Scotland minister, published the poem anonymously in 1790, and its world of potions, prayers and hushed footsteps is a community gathered round the sick.
The carers answer silence differently. The child in Baillie's poem answers it with more words, as if talk could keep the grandfather present. Armitage's speaker answers it with touch: the paired verbs "handle and hold", "mind and attend" and the wish to "feel the hurt" replace conversation with care. Form supports this. Armitage's couplets contain no dialogue at all, only the speaker's quiet account, and their irregular rhyme gives the poem a hushed, uneven music. Baillie's rhyming couplets, each stanza closing on a shorter line that usually ends with "dad", repeatedly address a man who cannot reply.
In the end, the silences move in opposite directions. Baillie's deepens, and the child's chatter is left unheard; Armitage's is slowly crossed, and the poem ends with the speaker able to "come close" without a word being spoken. Both poems show love working against silence, but one discovers its limits, and the other finds a language beyond speech.
Explanation
Level 5 answers compare the two silences and the responses to them: Baillie's talkative child, whose questions and stories meet a grandfather drifting beyond hearing, against Armitage's wordless care for a man whose silence comes from trauma, with attention to the absence of dialogue in Armitage's couplets and the unanswered refrain in Baillie's. Context, such as the documentary that first gave the poem a voice or Baillie's 1790 world of prayers and neighbours, should be integrated. Common errors are writing about one poem (capped at 8 marks), calling the speaker Armitage, and claiming that the poem itself (rather than its source title and the documentary) says the speaker is a wife.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO2 (15 marks), AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The writing is informed by perceptive comparisons and contrasts, with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and/or differences between the poems considered. There is perceptive grasp of form and structure and their effect. The response offers a cohesive evaluation of the poets' language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is integrated and precise. There is excellent understanding of context, and convincing understanding of the relationship between poems and context is integrated into the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and/or differences, and ideas are supported throughout with relevant examples from both poems. Analysis of form and structure and their effect is sustained. The candidate comments effectively on the poets' use of language and its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used accurately and appropriately to develop ideas. There is sustained comment on relevant context and detailed awareness of the relationship between poems and context.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and/or differences between the poems. The response shows a sound understanding of form and structure and links them to their effect. There is clear awareness, with sound examples, of the poets' use of language and of its effect on the reader. Relevant subject terminology is used to support examples given. There is sound comment on relevant context and sound relevant comment on the relationship between poems and context.
Level 2 (5-8 marks), Level 1 (1-4 marks): Pearson's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 8 if only one poem is considered (Pearson's mark scheme: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered). Pearson's grid: AO2 (15 marks) and AO3 (5 marks): in each level bullet 1 is comparison, bullets 2, 3 and 4 are AO2 and bullet 5 is AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 2 (5-8 marks): There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and/or differences, supported with some ideas from the poems. There is some comment on the form and structure of the poems. Some awareness of the poets' use of language is shown, but without development. Limited use of relevant subject terminology to support examples given. There is some awareness of relevant context and some comment on the relationship between poems and context. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is little or no comparison of the two poems. Identification of form and structure is minimal. There is little awareness of the language used by the poets. Little evidence of relevant subject terminology. There is little awareness of context and little comment on the relationship between poems and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points):
'The Manhunt' - form and structure (AO2):
- Thirteen couplets (26 lines); irregular rhyme, some full, many partial; a slow journey through the man's body (face, jaw, collar-bone, shoulder-blade, lung, ribs, heart, chest) to his mind, each stage marked by a repeated phrase of permission and time.
- No dialogue: everything is the speaker's account; closeness at the end comes without words.
Language (AO2):
- A man who never speaks, his jaw a "blown hinge"; consent given without words ("would he let me").
- Silence as self-protection: the "unexploded mine", nerves "tightened and closed"; the speaker answers silence with touch ("handle and hold", "mind and attend", "feel the hurt"); "come close".
Context (AO3):
- The poem was first heard in a 2007 television documentary in which former soldiers read Armitage's poems based on their own accounts.
Second poem: any suitable poem from the Relationships collection is credited. For example, 'A Child to his Sick Grandfather' (Joanna Baillie):
- Eight six-line stanzas of rhyming couplets; the refrain-like "dad" addresses someone who cannot answer; a dash before the last line.
- A talkative child: questions ("You will not die and leave us then?"), promises ("I'll sit and talk with you"), stories ("I have a tale both long and good"); the household's protective quiet ("We'll doff our shoes and softly tread"); the old man's growing silence ("you nod, I think?"; "You do not hear me, dad.").
- Baillie, a Church of Scotland minister's daughter, published the poem anonymously in 1790; the neighbours' prayers are part of its rural world.
Comparison:
- Two silent men cared for by someone who loves them.
- A poem full of the carer's speech against a poem in which care is wordless.
- Silence caused by age and illness against silence caused by trauma; one deepens, the other is slowly crossed. Pearson's mark schemes reward responses that compare the named poem to a substantial extent with a second poem. AO3 (5 marks) is the influence of the contexts in which the poems were written.