Question 1
20 marksA Christmas Carol: Charles Dickens
In Stave 1, Scrooge sits alone by a very low fire in his gloomy rooms.
Explain the importance of homes elsewhere in the novel.
In your answer, you must consider:
- the homes that Scrooge is shown
- what homes show about the people who live in them.
Model answer
Dickens rarely describes a house in A Christmas Carol without telling us something about the people inside it. A home in this novel can be a kind of prison, a place of fear or a refuge, and the difference never depends on money. It depends on whether anyone is cared for there, and that is why the homes Scrooge is shown teach him so much.
Some homes mirror neglect. The school where the young Scrooge is left is "a mansion of dull red brick", a house of "broken fortunes" whose rooms are "poorly furnished, cold, and vast". Its decay matches the loneliness of the boy inside it, and when Fan arrives to fetch him she says that home is now "like Heaven" because their father "is so much kinder than he used to be" - a hint that the family home was not always a refuge either. The bleakest house of all appears in Stave 4. The dead man lies in a dark, empty house with not a man, a woman or a child to speak kindly of him, while a cat tears at the door and rats gnaw "beneath the hearth-stone". A house that nobody visits has become a tomb before its owner is buried, and the reader sees the end of a life that shut everyone out.
Other homes show how one person's choices reach into the lives of others. Caroline's house is full of anxiety as she walks up and down, starts at every sound and can hardly bear her children's play while she waits for news of their debt. When she learns that the creditor has died, a death removes "so merciless a creditor" and gives them time to pay, so "it was a happier house for this man's death!" It is a disturbing idea: a cruel man's power has darkened a family's home, and only his death lightens it.
Against these, Dickens sets homes that are poor but warm. The miners' hut on the moor has a "wall of mud and stone", yet four generations gather round "a glowing fire" to sing. The Ghost of Christmas Present blesses Bob Cratchit's "four-roomed house", and as night falls the streets are full of homes, every house "piling up its fires half-chimney high" for visitors. What makes these homes is not comfort but welcome: their fires are lit for other people. That is why the silence of the Cratchits' home after Tiny Tim's death - "Quiet. Very quiet." - is so painful, because the family's grief shows how much love filled that home.
Finally, Dickens shows that a home can change when its owner does. In Stave 3 Scrooge's own room is transformed, "hung with living green", with a blaze such as that "dull petrification of a hearth" had never known; the Spirit seems to show him what his home could be. In Stave 5 he makes it real. At his nephew's house "He was at home in five minutes", and the next morning he tells Bob to "Make up the fires" in the office. The homes of the novel therefore trace Scrooge's journey in miniature: from a cold house shared with no one to a place at someone else's fire, and a willingness to warm the rooms of others.
Explanation
A Level 5 answer makes a clear argument about what homes reveal - for example homes that mirror neglect (the school, the dead man's house), homes darkened by fear (Caroline's), and poor but warm homes (the miners, the Cratchits) - with references from at least three different staves. Do not discuss Scrooge's evening by his own fire from the extract. Language analysis and context are not credited in part (b).
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 (20 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation. Discerning references are an integral part of the response, with points made with assurance and full support from the text.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text. The critical style is sustained and there is well-developed interpretation. Well-chosen references to the text support a range of effective points.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation. The response is relevant and focused points are made with support from the text.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of personal response. There is some evidence of a critical style but it is not always applied securely. Some valid points are made, but without consistent or secure focus.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): The response is simple with little personal response. There is little evidence of a critical style. Little reference is made to the content or themes of the text.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's grid: AO1 (20 marks). Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): AO1 (the novel elsewhere: relevant references, short quotations or paraphrase, from outside the extract). Responses may include:
The homes that Scrooge is shown:
- Stave 2: the school is "a mansion of dull red brick", a house of "broken fortunes" whose rooms are "poorly furnished, cold, and vast"; Fan says that now "home's like Heaven!", which suggests that it was not always so.
- Stave 3: Scrooge's own room is transformed by the Ghost of Christmas Present, "hung with living green", with a blaze that its "dull petrification of a hearth" had never known.
- Stave 3: the Spirit blesses Bob Cratchit's "four-roomed house"; the miners' hut has a "wall of mud and stone" but "a glowing fire" with four generations round it; in the streets, "every house expecting company" is "piling up its fires half-chimney high".
- Stave 4: the dead man lies in a dark, empty house where a cat tears at the door and rats gnaw "beneath the hearth-stone".
- Stave 4: Caroline paces her house in fear of their debt; a death removes "so merciless a creditor" and gives them time to pay, so "it was a happier house for this man's death!"; the Cratchits' home is "Quiet. Very quiet." after Tiny Tim's death.
What homes show about the people who live in them:
- A home mirrors the love or neglect of the people in it: the decaying school and the empty house of the dead man against the poor but warm homes of the miners and the Cratchits.
- Fear and debt can reach into a home from outside (Caroline); grief can empty it (the Cratchits) - homes show how one person's choices affect others.
- Stave 5: Scrooge finds a home at Fred's - "He was at home in five minutes" - and tells Bob to "Make up the fires", bringing warmth into his working life too. Part (b) assesses AO1 only (Pearson's mark scheme). Candidates will be rewarded if they make relevant textual references or use short quotations from elsewhere in the novel; this includes relevant paraphrasing (Pearson's mark scheme). Pearson's June 2023 examiners' report: for part (b) candidates should give examples from elsewhere in the novel and the extract should not be used; context and language are not assessed in this part; exact quotations are not mandatory in this closed-book examination.