Lewis made a pavlova. The table shows his method. The baked pavlova had three problems:
- it had a small volume
- it had a grainy, lumpy texture
- it was brown and cracked, with sticky beads of syrup on its surface.
For each problem, identify the step in Lewis's method that caused it, and explain how that step caused the problem. Use your knowledge of egg-white foams.
Do not repeat your answers.
Model answer
Small volume: step 1. The greasy film of buttercream left in the plastic bowl is a fat. Fat stops the unfolded egg-white proteins linking together to form a film around the air bubbles, so the bubbles burst and little air is trapped.
Grainy, lumpy texture: step 2. Whisking on full speed until the whites were dry and lumpy over-whisked them. The proteins were denatured too much and bonded too tightly, so the film around the bubbles became stiff and broke, and the foam separated into lumps that the sugar could not be whisked into smoothly.
Brown and cracked, with beads of syrup: step 5. 200 °C is far too hot; meringue should be dried slowly at about 120 °C. The egg-white proteins coagulated too quickly and too much, so they shrank and squeezed out water containing dissolved sugar, which formed sticky beads of syrup. The outside set quickly and cracked as the air inside expanded, and the sugar caramelised, turning the meringue brown.
Explanation
Each problem is worth up to two marks: one for identifying the step that caused it and one for explaining how it affected the egg-white proteins, the air or the sugar. Strong answers use the science of foams (proteins forming a film around air bubbles, over-denaturing, over-coagulation and syneresis) rather than just saying what Lewis should have done. A common mistake is to blame step 3, where the sugar was in fact added correctly, or to repeat 'not enough air' for every problem without explaining why.