A restaurant serves rare beef steaks. The chef now wants to add beef burgers, cooked so that they are pink in the middle, to the menu.
Explain why a beef burger served pink in the middle carries a greater risk of E. coli food poisoning than a rare steak, and how the risk of E. coli food poisoning from burgers can be controlled.
Model answer
E. coli lives in the guts of cattle. During slaughter, gut contents can contaminate the outside surface of the meat. In a whole steak the bacteria stay on the outside surface, while the inside is usually free of them. Searing the steak in a very hot pan destroys these surface bacteria, so a rare steak can be safe even though the middle is pink.
Mincing is different, because it mixes the surface of the meat, and any E. coli on it, all the way through the burger. If the burger is served pink in the middle, the centre may not reach 70 °C for 2 minutes, so the bacteria there survive. Only a few E. coli bacteria are needed to cause illness, which can be very serious, especially for young children and older people.
To control the risk, the chef should cook burgers until a clean probe in the centre reads at least 75 °C, with no pink meat and juices that run clear. Raw mince should be kept covered on the bottom shelf of the fridge at 0-5 °C and prepared on a separate red board, and staff should wash their hands after shaping burgers. To serve pink burgers, the restaurant would first have to tell the local authority, buy mince from a specially approved supplier and warn on the menu that vulnerable people should choose well-done burgers.
Explanation
Top answers explain the key difference: on a whole steak the bacteria are on the surface, where searing kills them, but mincing spreads them through the burger, so its centre must be cooked thoroughly. They then give controls linked to E. coli, such as a core temperature checked with a probe. A common pitfall is to say that burgers 'contain more bacteria' without explaining why mincing makes the centre unsafe.