Jordan is 19 and weighs 75 kg. He trains at a gym five times a week and wants to build muscle. He eats meat or fish at every meal and also has three protein shakes a day. His protein intake is about 190 g a day.
The reference nutrient intake (RNI) for protein for adults is 0.75 g per kg of body weight per day.
Explain the possible effects on Jordan's health of eating this much protein, and the advice you would give him.
Model answer
Jordan's RNI is 0.75 × 75 = 56.25 g, so 190 g is more than three times what he needs and well over the UK advice not to eat more than twice the RNI. His body cannot store the extra protein. It is broken down in the liver and the nitrogen is removed by the kidneys as urea, which puts extra strain on both organs. The rest is used for energy, and if he eats more energy than he uses it is stored as fat, so he could gain body fat rather than muscle. Extra protein does not build extra muscle; training does.
Eating meat at every meal could also mean a lot of saturated fat, which raises LDL cholesterol and the risk of heart disease, and processed meat is high in salt and linked to bowel cancer. If the shakes replace starchy foods, fruit and vegetables, he will have less carbohydrate for energy when training, less fibre and fewer vitamins.
I would advise Jordan to stop most of the shakes, because his meals already give him more protein than his RNI. He should spread protein over his meals, with a snack such as yoghurt or eggs on toast after training. He should choose lean meat and fish and include beans and lentils, and base his meals on wholegrain starchy foods with plenty of fruit and vegetables, following the Eatwell Guide.
Explanation
Top-level answers use the data (56.25 g RNI against 190 g) and explain why too much protein matters: the strain on the liver and kidneys, excess energy stored as fat, and the saturated fat that comes with a lot of meat. They then give advice that is specific to Jordan's training. Weak answers just say 'too much protein is bad for you', or give advice without explaining the effects.