Sam's family has started using a low-fat spread instead of butter. The spread contains about 38% fat; butter contains about 82% fat.
Sam used the low-fat spread to make shortcrust pastry for a cheese and onion quiche, and the pastry was hard and tough. He also used it to fry the onions for the filling; it spat in the pan, and the onions stuck and started to burn.
Explain why the low-fat spread caused these two problems.
Model answer
Pastry: the low-fat spread is only about 38% fat, so more than half of it is water. There is not enough fat to coat and waterproof the flour particles, and the water in the spread is absorbed by the flour proteins, so long gluten strands develop and the pastry is tough instead of short.
Frying: when the spread is heated, its water turns to steam, which makes it spit. Once the water has boiled away there is very little fat left in the pan, so the onions stick and burn.
Explanation
Low-fat spreads replace much of the fat with water, held in a water-in-oil emulsion, so they cannot shorten pastry and are not suitable for frying. The best answers explain each problem with a cause and its effect, linked to the high water content. A common mistake is to answer about health rather than how the spread behaves when cooked.