A juice bar at a railway station sells pear, banana and orange smoothies. Each smoothie is made by blending a peeled pear and a banana with 150 ml of freshly squeezed orange juice.
To save time in the morning rush, staff make all the smoothies at 6 am. They pour them into clear plastic bottles, filling each bottle about three-quarters full, and put them on an open chiller shelf until they are sold, up to 4 pm.
By the afternoon, the smoothies have changed from pale yellow to a dull beige-brown, and tests show that they contain less vitamin C than freshly made smoothies.
Explain why the smoothies change colour and lose vitamin C, and how the juice bar could reduce these changes.
Model answer
Blending breaks open almost every cell in the pear and banana, releasing enzymes, and it whisks air into the smoothie. The enzymes react with oxygen to form brown pigments; this enzymic browning turns the smoothie from pale yellow to beige-brown. The acid in the orange juice lowers the pH and slows the enzymes at first, but over up to ten hours it is not enough to stop them.
Vitamin C, mostly from the orange juice, is oxidised by oxygen in the air bubbles and in the air at the top of each bottle, which is only three-quarters full. Blended fruit has a huge surface area, so oxidation is fast. The open chiller shelf slows the reactions but does not stop them, and it may be warmer than a fridge as customers take bottles out. Light through the clear bottles also speeds up the loss of vitamin C.
The juice bar could blend smoothies in small batches through the day, or to order, so that they are drunk soon after blending. Bottles should be filled to the top and sealed straight away, so little air is left in them, and opaque bottles would keep out light. Keeping them at 0-5 °C and adding a little lemon juice would also slow both changes.
Explanation
Top-level answers explain both changes with the science (enzymes released by blending reacting with oxygen, and vitamin C being oxidised) and link them to details in the question: the air whisked in, the part-filled clear bottles, the long time and the chiller shelf. Suggested changes must follow from these causes. Answers that only list ways to prevent browning, or that describe the changes without explaining them, stay in Level 1 or 2.