A supermarket wants to buy 1 tonne of fresh asparagus in March, when it is not in season in the UK. It could buy it from one of two growers:
- Route A: grown in Peru, flown about 10,000 km to the UK, then taken 100 km by lorry to the supermarket's depot
- Route B: grown in Spain, taken about 1,800 km by lorry to the depot.
The table shows approximate greenhouse gas emissions for moving 1 tonne of food 1 km by different types of transport.
Use: emissions = distance (km) × emissions for 1 tonne per km.
Calculate the greenhouse gas emissions from transporting 1 tonne of asparagus by Route A and by Route B, and how many times greater the emissions from Route A are than those from Route B.
Suggest why asparagus from Peru is sent to the UK by plane rather than by ship.
Model answer
Route A: (10,000 × 0.6) + (100 × 0.1) = 6,000 + 10 = 6,010 kg
Route B: 1,800 × 0.1 = 180 kg
6,010 ÷ 180 = 33.4, so Route A releases about 33 times more greenhouse gas than Route B.
Asparagus spoils quickly. A ship from Peru would take weeks, so the asparagus would not arrive fresh, but a plane gets it to the UK in less than a day.
Explanation
Multiply each distance by the figure for that type of transport and add both parts of Route A: the flight alone gives 6,000 kg, because a plane releases six times more than a lorry and 40 times more than a ship for each tonne per km. Common mistakes are leaving out the lorry part of Route A and dividing the wrong way round. Perishable foods are flown because sea journeys are too slow, which is why air-freighted produce has such a large carbon footprint.