Question 1
2 marksHere is a statement.
'\((x + 3)^{2} > x^{2} + 9\) for all values of \(x\)'
Show that the statement is false.
Type powers with \(\text{\textasciicircum}\), for example \(\text{x\textasciicircum 2}\).
Model answer
When \(x = -1\):
\((x + 3)^{2} = (-1 + 3)^{2} = 2^{2} = 4\)
\(x^{2} + 9 = (-1)^{2} + 9 = 10\)
4 is not greater than 10
So \((x + 3)^{2} > x^{2} + 9\) is not true for all values of \(x\): the statement is false.
Explanation
One counterexample is enough to show that a statement 'for all values' is false. Expanding, \((x + 3)^{2} = x^{2} + 6x + 9\), which is greater than \(x^{2} + 9\) only when \(6x > 0\), so any \(x \le 0\) is a counterexample. A common error is to try only positive values, which all agree with the statement; another is to treat \((x + 3)^{2}\) as \(x^{2} + 9\).
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
M1 for a value of \(x \le 0\) substituted correctly into both sides, eg \(x = -1\): \((-1 + 3)^2 = 4\) and \((-1)^2 + 9 = 10\)
Any \(x \le 0\) works, eg \(x = 0\): both sides are 9; \(x = -2\): 1 and 13; \(x = -3\): 0 and 18. A positive value of \(x\) makes the statement true for that value and scores 0. Alternative method: M1 for \((x + 3)^2 = x^2 + 6x + 9\), or \((x + 3)^2 - (x^2 + 9) = 6x\).
-
1 mark
A1 for a correct conclusion, eg '4 is not greater than 10, so the statement is false'
For \(x = 0\) the conclusion must say that the two sides are equal (9 is not greater than 9). Alternative method: A1 for '\(6x \le 0\) when \(x \le 0\), so \((x + 3)^2\) is not greater than \(x^2 + 9\) for these values' oe. This is a 'show that' question: a value with no working (eg just '\(x = -1\)', without both sides evaluated) scores 0, and an answer that only restates that the statement is false scores 0. Several counterexamples are fine, but an incorrect one (eg claiming \(x = 1\) works) is A0.