Question 1
1 markTwo students each burned a 1.0 g piece of the same cracker under a boiling tube of water. Student 1 used 10 cm³ of water. Student 2 used 20 cm³ of water. The water in both tubes started at the same temperature.
Assume that the same amount of energy was transferred to the water in each tube.
Which statement is correct?
Choose your answer.
- A student 2's rise is half as big
- B student 2's rise is twice as big
- C the two rises are the same
- D student 2 finds more energy per g
Model answer
A - the temperature rise for student 2 is half as big as for student 1.
Explanation
The energy needed to raise the temperature of water depends on its mass: 4.2 J raises 1 g of water by 1 °C. With the same energy, twice the mass of water rises by half as many degrees, so both students should calculate the same energy per gram. A common error is to think more water gives a bigger temperature rise.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / student 2's rise is half as big (1)
The only correct answer is A: twice the mass of water heated by the same energy has half the temperature rise of student 1's water. B is not correct because twice the mass of water needs twice the energy for each degree of temperature rise, so the same energy gives a smaller rise, not a larger one; C is not correct because the temperature rise depends on the mass of water being heated; D is not correct because energy content = mass of water × temperature rise × 4.2 ÷ mass of food, so twice the mass of water with half the rise gives the same energy per g. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.