Figure 1 is part of a resource booklet about land use in Norrbotten, northern Sweden. The views were written for this course and are not those of real people.
Figure 1: Five views about new mines and wind farms in Norrbotten
- A reindeer herder from a mountain Sami village near Jokkmokk: "Our reindeer spend the summer in the mountains near Laponia and the winter in the forest. A mine, a wind farm, a power line, a clear-cut - each one alone looks small. Together they cut our migration routes and take the lichen our herds need. We already have to move reindeer by lorry. Our culture depends on the land, not on compensation money."
- A spokesperson for a mining company: "Europe needs iron ore for the steel in wind turbines, electric cars and railways, and it is better mined here, under strict environmental laws, than imported from far away. A mine would create jobs and bring young families back to Jokkmokk. We will plan our transport around the reindeer migrations."
- An engineer at a 'fossil-free' steel plant near Luleå: "Making steel with hydrogen instead of coal could cut Sweden's carbon dioxide emissions by about a tenth. But each plant needs huge amounts of fossil-free electricity, so we need more wind farms and power lines in the north, and the iron ore has to come from somewhere."
- A member of a wilderness conservation group: "Laponia and the forests around it are among the last large wild areas in Europe. An open-pit mine less than 40 km away, with dust, heavy lorries and a tailings pond, would scar the landscape that visitors come to see and threaten wildlife. 'Green' industry should not destroy green land."
- A forest owner near Boden: "Forestry pays my bills and supplies timber, pulp and biofuel that replace oil and plastic. I already leave some old trees standing for the lichens. If clear-felling were banned in grazing areas my income would fall, but I would accept a fair deal with the herders."
Using evidence from Figure 1 and your own knowledge, assess which of the conflicts over land in Norrbotten shown in Figure 1 is likely to be the most difficult to resolve.
Model answer
Figure 1 shows several conflicts over the same land. The reindeer herder is in conflict with the mining company, with the engineer who wants more wind farms and power lines, and, over the lichens, with the forest owner. The conservation group also disagrees with the engineer about whether 'green' industry is really green.
The conflict between the forest owner and the herders looks the easiest to resolve. The forest owner already leaves some old trees standing for the lichens and says they would accept a fair deal with the herders. Selective felling in the most important winter-grazing areas, with compensation for lost income, could meet both their needs.
The conflict with the mining company is harder. The company says it would plan its transport around the reindeer migrations, which could reduce one problem. However, an open pit and a tailings pond would take land for many years, and the herder says that compensation money cannot replace the land their culture depends on.
In my judgement, the most difficult conflict to resolve is between the herders and the growing demand for wind farms, power lines and iron ore for 'fossil-free' steel. The engineer says hydrogen steel could cut Sweden's carbon dioxide emissions by about a tenth, so the pressure comes from a national and even global need, not from one company that could be persuaded to change its plans. There are also many separate projects spread across the grazing land. As the herder says, each one looks small, but together they cut the migration routes and take the lichen. Because the herders' losses are cumulative and cultural, they are very hard to compensate. The conservation group's view that 'green' industry should not destroy green land shows that this is also a clash of values.
Overall, the conflicts with the forest owner and even the mining company could be reduced by local agreements, but the conflict over the energy transition is the hardest to resolve, because it can only be eased if all the projects are planned together with the Sami villages.
Explanation
Level 3 answers use the views as evidence to identify the different conflicts and judge how far each could be resolved, considering whether losses are permanent, whether compensation or compromise is possible and how many projects are involved. Answers that simply summarise each view in turn, without judging which conflict is hardest to resolve, do not get beyond Level 2.