Study Figure 1, a map of the lower Tapajos and Xingu rivers in Brazil, which shows the site of the planned Sao Luiz do Tapajos dam, whose licensing was stopped in 2016.
Figure 2 (facts from ISA (2020), Mongabay (2017), Fiocruz (2020) and Brazil's Ministry of Justice (2024); the views were written for this course)
- There are about 18,000 Munduruku, and most live along the Tapajos and its tributaries. Fish is their main source of animal protein.
- The Munduruku say that the Sete Quedas rapids on the Teles Pires, a headwater of the Tapajos, were a sacred place. The rapids were blasted with explosives when dams were built on the river.
- In 2017 about 200 Munduruku occupied the construction site of the Sao Manoel dam on the Teles Pires.
- In September 2024 Brazil's Ministry of Justice declared Sawre Muybu (about 178,000 hectares) to be Munduruku land; ratification by the President is still to come.
- In a 2019 study, about 6 in 10 people tested in three Munduruku villages had more mercury in their bodies than the safe limit, because gold mining pollutes the fish.
- A Munduruku community leader: 'The river feeds us and holds the places where our ancestors live. Money cannot replace a sacred place.'
- A fisher from a riverside village: 'My family fishes, grows cassava and collects Brazil nuts. In the wet season the river spreads into the forest and the fish follow it to feed and breed. Our catch depends on that flood.'
Using evidence from Figures 1 and 2 and your own knowledge, assess the importance of the Tapajos river and its forests to the Munduruku and other riverside people.
Model answer
The Tapajos river and its forests are extremely important to the Munduruku and other riverside people, and the most important reason is food. Figure 2 shows that fish is the Munduruku's main source of animal protein, so the river directly feeds most of the 18,000 or so Munduruku. The fisher explains that catches depend on the wet-season flood, when the river spreads into the forest and fish follow it to feed and breed. This means the river and the forest work together as one food system, so a dam that changed the flood would affect people's diets as well as wildlife.
The river is also important for culture and identity. The community leader says the river holds sacred places that money cannot replace, and the Munduruku say the Sete Quedas rapids were destroyed when dams were built on the Teles Pires. This kind of importance is different from food: a sacred place cannot be rebuilt or compensated for, so its loss is permanent.
The forest also provides other goods, such as Brazil nuts, building materials, medicines and fuel wood, and the fisher's family grows cassava on land beside the river. These matter for their livelihoods, but some of them could be replaced by bought goods if people had incomes, so they are less important than fish and sacred places.
People's actions show how much they value the river. In 2017 about 200 Munduruku occupied a dam construction site, and after years of campaigning their Sawre Muybu land, about 178,000 hectares along the Tapajos, was declared Munduruku land by the Ministry of Justice in 2024, although the President has still to ratify it. Figure 1 shows that the planned Sao Luiz do Tapajos dam lay on the river they depend on.
The river's value is already under threat. About 6 in 10 people tested in three villages had unsafe mercury levels because gold mining pollutes the fish. This shows how dependent people are, because when the river is polluted their main food becomes a health risk and they have few alternatives.
Overall, the river and forests are of the greatest importance, because they provide the main food supply and the sacred places at the centre of Munduruku culture. Food is most important for survival, but culture is the least replaceable, which is why many Munduruku oppose new dams so strongly.