Guyana began producing oil in December 2019. Some people think its oil wealth will help it to protect its forest; others think it will lead to more of the forest being cleared.
Study Figure 1, which gives information about Guyana's forest carbon credits. It comes from a resource booklet about Guyana written for this course, using information from the Government of Guyana.
Figure 2 (written for this course using information from the Government of Guyana, the Guyana Forestry Commission and the World Bank; the views were written for this course)
- In 2025 about USD 2.4 billion of oil money was paid into Guyana's Natural Resource Fund, and about USD 2.46 billion was taken out to pay for the national budget.
- Between 2015 and 2025 Guyana lost only about 0.5% of its forest area.
- In 2020 mining, mostly for gold, caused 63% of the forest cleared. Most clearing was close to roads and to rivers that boats can use, and it rose when gold prices were high.
- Ravi, a builder in Georgetown: 'Oil has brought jobs. Spend the money now on roads, houses and cheaper electricity.'
- Grace, a conservation scientist: 'The forest earns money only while it is standing. New roads bring miners and loggers.'
Using evidence from Figures 1 and 2 and your own knowledge, assess whether Guyana's oil wealth is more likely to help to protect its forest or to lead to more of it being cleared.
Model answer
Guyana's oil wealth could help to protect its forest in several ways. With about USD 2.4 billion of oil money paid into the Natural Resource Fund in 2025 alone, the government does not need to earn money by clearing forest for farming, logging or mining, so it can afford to keep its Low Carbon Development Strategy. Oil money could also pay for satellite monitoring and rangers to stop illegal mining, and for other jobs for villagers and miners. Oil wealth and forest protection are already linked: Hess, a US oil company, agreed to buy 37.5 million forest carbon credits for at least USD 750 million, and at least 15% of the credit money goes to Amerindian villages. So far the forest has been well protected: Guyana lost only about 0.5% of its forest area between 2015 and 2025.
However, oil wealth could also lead to more clearing. Most of the oil money is spent rather than saved: in 2025 about USD 2.46 billion was taken out of the fund for the national budget. Ravi wants it spent on roads, and Grace warns that new roads bring miners and loggers. Figure 2 shows that most clearing happens close to roads and rivers, so roads into the interior are probably the biggest risk. Carbon credits have earned only about USD 353 million since 2022, far less than the oil money paid into the fund in one year, so the government may care less about keeping the forest standing. Oil wealth also does nothing to stop gold mining, which caused most of the clearing in 2020 and rises when gold prices are high. Finally, burning oil adds to climate change, which could bring more droughts and fires to the forest.
Overall, oil wealth makes it possible to protect the forest, but it does not make it certain. In the short term the very low rate of forest loss suggests that the money is helping, but in the long term the roads and growth that oil money pays for are a serious threat. Whether oil wealth protects or harms the forest depends on how the government chooses to spend it, especially whether it builds roads into the interior and controls gold mining.