Examine the presentation of Aunt Ranjan in Western Lane.
You must consider the context of the novel in your answer.
Model answer
Aunt Ranjan is one of the most divisive characters in Western Lane. Seen through the eyes of a grieving eleven-year-old, she can appear an interfering, judgemental figure who threatens to break up the family. Yet Maroo gives her more depth than that. She is a woman with fixed views about how girls should behave, but also a relative who cares, cooks, offers a home and, in the end, changes her mind.
Ranjan is introduced at the meal in Edinburgh soon after Ma's death. She is Uncle Pavan's wife and Pa's sister-in-law, and she and Pavan are comfortably off and have no children. Her judgement of the girls is blunt: they have become "wild" and need discipline and exercise. She criticises their behaviour in her kitchen, and she suggests that one of them could come to live with her and Uncle Pavan. To the sisters this is a threat, and Gopi's narration conveys their unease. Maroo presents Ranjan as someone who says what others leave unspoken, which makes her both abrasive and, in a novel full of silences, oddly honest.
Her words have consequences. The squash regime begins soon after the visit, and the older narrator suggests that Aunt Ranjan's warning was one possible cause, though she also weighs other explanations, such as Uncle Pavan's talk about the past. In this sense Ranjan helps to set the plot in motion: Pa's training of the girls can be read partly as his answer to her doubts.
Maroo also shows Ranjan's care. When Gopi, worried by Pa's behaviour, telephones Uncle Pavan, Ranjan comes with her husband to stay and cooks for the family. Her offer of a home, repeated when Gopi is invited to live in Edinburgh, can be read as generosity rather than interference. For a childless couple, taking in a niece may be an act of love as well as a way of putting things right, and in many South Asian families it is not unusual for relatives to help bring up a brother's child.
When Gopi lives with her, Ranjan's strictness returns. At first she refuses to let Gopi play in the Durham and Cleveland tournament. The novel does not present this simply as cruelty: her views on what is proper for a girl reflect the traditional expectations of her generation, and she may be wary of the world of the squash club and of competition. Gopi raises the subject carefully, and it is Uncle Pavan who quietly persuades his wife to change her mind. That Ranjan does change suggests that she is capable of growth.
The relationship between Ranjan and Pavan is also revealing. Ranjan is the more forceful speaker, while Pavan works through gentle persuasion. In a household where traditional expectations might place authority with the husband, their partnership complicates any simple picture of gender roles, and it shows that Ranjan's influence is real.
The context shapes Ranjan's portrayal. In British Gujarati families, older relatives often expect a say in how children are raised, especially after a death, and a family's reputation in the community matters. A widower raising three girls alone in the 1980s might seem to such relatives a cause for concern. Ranjan's ideas about modesty, domestic skills and proper behaviour represent an older generation's values, which the sisters, with their English schooling and their sport, find restrictive. Readers have responded to her differently: some see her as a voice of restrictive, even sexist expectations, while others stress her kindness and her care for the family.
Maroo's narrative method complicates our view of her. Because Gopi is a child, she sees Ranjan's criticisms more clearly than her motives. The older narrator, looking back, is fairer, allowing the reader to see that Ranjan's harshness comes from anxiety and love as well as from fixed opinions.
In conclusion, Maroo presents Aunt Ranjan as a complex figure rather than a villain. She embodies the pressures of family and community expectation that weigh on the sisters, especially as girls, but she is also a source of practical care and, in the end, of support. Her movement from condemning the girls as wild to allowing Gopi to compete reflects the novel's wider movement from judgement towards understanding.