Question 1
20 marksFive A.M., Mumbai
The city has not put its voices on.
A sweeper's broom confides in the bare street;
a milk van idles; fishing boats, half gone
in mist, come home with silver at their feet.
The sea is flat and grey as a steel tray.
Along the promenade the walkers pass
in ones and twos, and crows rehearse the day
on every ledge and wire and pane of glass.
Then, from the station, one long whistle blows,
and like a breath held far too long, the roar
comes rushing out: the horns, the shutters, those
twelve million voices pouring through each door.
I keep that hour the way you keep a shell,
to hold against the noise, and hear the swell.
Explore how the writer presents the city in this poem.
In your answer, you should consider the poet's:
- descriptive skills
- choice of language
- use of structure and form.
Support your answer with examples from the poem.
Model answer
The writer presents Mumbai as a city with two faces: a hushed, almost secret city before dawn, and a roaring, crowded one once the day begins. The sonnet form, usually associated with love poetry, suggests that this is a kind of love poem to the city, and to the quiet hour that the speaker wants to keep.
The opening line personifies the city: it "has not put its voices on". Noise is presented as something the city wears, like clothing, so in this early hour we glimpse it undressed and private. The verb "confides" in "A sweeper's broom confides in the bare street" continues this intimacy: the soft, sibilant sound of the broom becomes a whispered secret, and the adjective "bare" stresses emptiness. The descriptive details are carefully chosen to show the working people who wake the city before anyone else: the sweeper, the milk van, the fishing boats "half gone / in mist". The metaphor "silver at their feet" turns the catch into treasure, suggesting the richness of the sea that feeds the city.
The simile "flat and grey as a steel tray" makes the sea calm and ordinary, an everyday object rather than a wild force. The walkers who pass "in ones and twos" show how few people are about, while "crows rehearse the day" is a witty personification: the day is a performance that has not yet begun, and the crows are practising their parts. The polysyndeton of "on every ledge and wire and pane of glass" slows the line, spreading the crows across the whole city.
The volta comes at the start of the third quatrain with "Then", when "one long whistle blows" from the station. The simile "like a breath held far too long" suggests that the quiet hour was a kind of tension, and the noise is a release that cannot be stopped. The verbs "rushing" and "pouring" create a flood of sound, and the list "the horns, the shutters, those / twelve million voices" builds rapidly. The enjambment after "those" makes the line overflow, enacting the crowds spilling out "through each door". The number "twelve million" contrasts sharply with the single sweeper and the "ones and twos" earlier, so the sonnet is built on the contrast between few and many, silence and noise.
The rhyming couplet gives the speaker's personal response. "I keep that hour the way you keep a shell" presents the memory of dawn as a treasured keepsake, small enough to carry. The final line, "to hold against the noise, and hear the swell", completes the image: just as a shell held to the ear seems to contain the sound of the sea, the memory lets the speaker hear the calm of dawn in the middle of the city's roar. The full rhyme of "shell" and "swell" gives a sense of peace and closure.
The regular iambic pentameter and alternate rhymes give the first eight lines an unhurried, measured quality, matching the slow waking of the city. Even when the noise arrives, the form contains it, perhaps suggesting that the speaker can hold the city's chaos inside a calm frame.
Overall, the writer presents the city as both overwhelming and tender. Through personification, contrast and the turn of the sonnet, the poem suggests that the true character of a great city may be found in the brief, quiet hour that most people never see.
Explanation
This question tests whether you can use the sonnet's structure to explain how the city is presented, not just list what the speaker sees. Track the contrast between the quiet opening quatrains and the noisy third quatrain, and explain what the volta and the final couplet show about the speaker's feelings. A common mistake is to identify the sonnet form without saying why it suits a poem about loving a place.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO2 (20 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The response is a cohesive evaluation of the interrelationship of the language, form and structure used by the writer and their effect on the reader. Discriminating use of relevant examples to support the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response is focused and detailed, and the analysis of the language, form and structure used by the writer and their effect on the reader is sustained. Use of fully relevant examples to support the response.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response shows an understanding of the range of language, form and structure used by the writer and links these to their effect on the reader. Use of clearly relevant examples to support the response.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): The response may be largely descriptive, with some comment on the language, form and structure used by the writer. Some use of relevant examples to support the response.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): The response is simple and the identification of language, form and structure used by the writer is minimal. Limited use of relevant examples to support the response.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid, well-supported points and interpretations). This poem was written for this course. AO2 (descriptive skills): the poem shows Mumbai in the quiet hour before dawn (a sweeper, a milk van, fishing boats returning through mist, a flat grey sea, a few walkers, crows), then the sudden noise of the waking city after a train whistle; the speaker treasures the memory of the quiet hour. AO2 (choice of language): the personification "The city has not put its voices on" presents noise as something the city wears, so dawn shows it private and undressed; "confides" and the sibilance of "A sweeper's broom confides in the bare street" create intimacy and secrecy; the metaphor "silver at their feet" turns the catch into treasure; the simile "flat and grey as a steel tray" makes the sea calm and domestic; "crows rehearse the day" presents the day as a performance not yet begun; the polysyndeton of "every ledge and wire and pane of glass" spreads the crows across the city; the simile "like a breath held far too long" presents the noise as an unstoppable release; the verbs "rushing" and "pouring" and the list "the horns, the shutters, those / twelve million voices" create a flood of sound; the final simile "the way you keep a shell" presents the memory as a keepsake that lets the speaker "hear the swell" of calm against "the noise". AO2 (structure and form): a Shakespearean sonnet (ABAB CDCD EFEF GG) in iambic pentameter; a form traditionally used for love poetry suggests a love poem to the city; the first two quatrains are quiet and slow, and the volta comes with "Then" at the start of the third quatrain; contrast structures the poem (few and many, silence and roar: "ones and twos" against "twelve million"); the enjambment after "those" makes the line overflow like the crowds; the rhyming couplet gives the speaker's personal response and a calm closure ("shell" and "swell"). Weaker responses list the sights or name the sonnet form without linking it to meaning (Level 2); stronger responses explore how the turn and the contrast present the city's two faces and the speaker's feelings about them (Level 4-5).