Re-read Half-past Two in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present power in Half-past Two and one other poem from the anthology.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Half-past Two and My Last Duchess both explore power through a figure of authority who controls another person, and in both the powerless person is never allowed to speak. However, Fanthorpe's teacher exercises power carelessly, through forgetfulness, and the child finally escapes it, whereas Browning's Duke exercises power deliberately and sinisterly, and his wife's only escape is death.
Both poets show power through the way authority is spoken about. In Half-past Two some of the teacher's pronouns are capitalised ("She", "Her desk"), as if she were a queen or a god, and her verdict that the boy has done "Something Very Wrong" is repeated in capitals, as though it were an official charge. We never learn what the offence was: the adult narrator admits "(I forget what it was)". The capitals show how absolute adult power seems to a child, while the bracket gently mocks it. Browning's Duke needs no capital letters: his power is in his voice, which fills the whole poem. As a dramatic monologue, My Last Duchess gives only the Duke's words, so his wife and the envoy are silenced. He boasts of "My gift of a nine-hundred-years-old name", showing that his power rests on rank and lineage.
The powerless figures are alike in their silence. Fanthorpe's boy is "too scared at being wicked" to remind the teacher that she has never taught him to tell the time, so fear keeps him silent and he suffers an unfair punishment. The Duchess's offence, in the Duke's eyes, is that she was too easily pleased: "she liked whate'er / She looked on, and her looks went everywhere." Like the boy, she has done nothing truly wrong; it is the authority figure's judgement that makes her guilty.
The sharpest contrast lies in how power is used. Fanthorpe's teacher does not intend cruelty; she simply forgets. When she returns she admits "I forgot all about you" and "slotted him back into schooltime", a mechanical verb suggesting that she treats him as a part to be fitted back into the system rather than as a person. Her power is careless and impersonal. The Duke's power is calculated and deadly: "I gave commands; / Then all smiles stopped together." The euphemism hides a murder in two short clauses, and the ease with which he says it is chilling.
Both authority figures control time and space. The teacher's power works through clock time: the boy must stay until half-past two, but he cannot "click its language", so time becomes a code that adults control. The Duke controls who may look at his wife's portrait, since "none puts by / The curtain I have drawn for you, but I". He now possesses the Duchess as an object on the wall, frozen in time, "Looking as if she were alive".
Yet the poems end differently. Fanthorpe allows the child to escape the teacher's power: by not knowing time, he slips into "the clockless land for ever", a fairy-tale world that adult control cannot reach. Power is shown to have limits, and the child's imagination is stronger than the teacher's rules. Browning's Duke ends by pointing out a bronze of Neptune "Taming a sea-horse", a symbol of his own wish to dominate, and the reader realises that the next Duchess, the Count's daughter, may suffer the same fate. His power continues unchecked.
Form reinforces these ideas. Browning's rhyming couplets in iambic pentameter are controlled, like the Duke himself, but frequent enjambment almost hides the rhymes, so his polished speech conceals menace. Fanthorpe's eleven tercets of free verse are gentle and story-like, and the bracketed asides let an adult voice comment on the authority it once feared.
In conclusion, both poets show power over the vulnerable and the silencing of those without it. Fanthorpe presents everyday, thoughtless authority that a child's imagination can escape, while Browning presents a ruthless power that destroys, and leaves the reader disturbed by how calmly it is exercised.